Ministers have said there are still challenges to delivering the programme rebuilding the submarine berths at Devonport and that the delivery team is working with the assurance authority and the contractor to recover it, according to an answer given in Parliament.
James MacCleary, the Liberal Democrat member for Lewes, asked what progress has been made on the Submarine Waterfront Infrastructure Future programme in the context of the delivery confidence assessments for Government Major Project Portfolio defence projects.
Luke Pollard, Minister of State for Defence, said: “The delivery confidence assessment for the Submarine Waterfront Infrastructure Future (SWIF) programme reflects the likelihood of successful delivery at a specific point in time and the National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA) Gate Review process is an integral part of the Assurance Framework that the Ministry of Defence has in place to support project delivery.
“Despite positive progress, there are still challenges to the delivery of the SWIF programme. The delivery team is working closely with NISTA and the contractor to recover the programme. The current focus is on the completion of design work, where we have increased the pace of design decisions and streamlined approvals, to enable the start of construction. We have used the principles set out in the Nuclear Regulatory Review as part of these reviews, to identify new opportunities to accelerate work.”
Devonport is the only dockyard in Britain licensed to refit nuclear submarines, and the waterfront infrastructure there handles the Astute class, the decommissioned boats still laid up in the basin, and the deep maintenance periods that keep the attack submarine flotilla available.
Availability in that flotilla has been the subject of repeated criticism, and the Defence Committee reported this month that availability among destroyers, frigates and attack submarines raises questions about whether Britain can meet its commitments in the High North, and the refit of HMS Vanguard at Devonport ran to seven and a half years against an original plan of three and a half.
The Nuclear Regulatory Review was commissioned to reduce the time regulatory approvals add to nuclear programmes, and its principles are now being applied to the design decisions on the waterfront. Defence has committed more than £2 billion to Devonport infrastructure over the coming decade.
Work at the dockyard runs alongside the Clyde Infrastructure programme at Faslane and Coulport, where ministers declined to give an updated assessment and said the next set of delivery confidence figures will come from information captured on 31 March 2027.











Anyone care to translate what this article just said?
It’s late, over cost, and no one knows how to even design it. So go whistle for it ever being finished, because someone will cancel it.
ie, situation MOD normal.
JB,
🤔😁👍
With three floating dry docks going in to HMNB Clyde and considerable expense is it worth asking the question of why we need more shore based dry docks at Devonport.
These facilities are insanely expensive and if all the boats are being based on the Clyde why not just keep the entire maintenance process on the Clyde.
£2billion is a chunk of change.
Because we can’t rely on Scotland if they go independent
Because you can’t do deep refits in a floating dry dock, any more than you can in a ship lift. You need a graving docks and Faslane has bad geology for them. Project Euston will replace the ship lift for hull work, and supposedly support up to 16 boats.
There are four submarine-related graving docks at Devonport. No 9 is for SSBNs, and is currently working on Victorious. No 15 is for SSNs and is between refits. No 10 Dock is being refurbished and will be able to handle either SSBNs or SSNs, target date next year, but maybe 2028 in reality.. No 14 will be used for defuelling decommissioned boats, and is currently in rebuild. There’s one more dry rock on the submarine list: No 3 Dock at Rosyth, which will handle contingency berthing but not deep refit. That last one is many years down the line.
First three paragraphs, I will simplify the bluster for those who get bored reading such HMG chuff. “We fucked up, its not going right, we underfunded and overestimated the ability of the contractor, but we wont ever ever admit that, and we will use secrecy rules to avoid telling anyone the truth, both regarding cost and our level of incompetence”.
And no the water in the Prince of Wales Basin is fine.. who says it makes you glow in the dark.. look we will even get ministers X kids to drink it.
Its called “the glowstick filling pool” mate, new side line with Temu to make a few quid….
Airborne,
🤣😂👍. My vote for best and most amusing commentary of the week! 👍👍
You are far too kind.
Borners has this talent ….
I hope this comment is read by millions.
MILLIONS.
It won’t be as most people don’t care about defence.
There’s that Delusion of yours again….. 😁… no offence Intended…….but only a handful read this site and even some of those are blocked now…… Unless you are David Lloyd who seems to be able to hurl Insults around.
3.5 page views last month isn’t a “handful”.
Ah, Mr Halfwit, you’re back.
I knew you would be. I understood many hundreds of thousands read UKDJ.
Whatever. It’s the go to site for Defence matters in the UK as far as I’m concerned.
No offence taken either. 🙂
Funny. You posted this Nov1st and I was only notified of this today, hence the delay in replying.
Assume you were moderated.
TBH I think you are maybe being a little unkind, these 4 docks were originally built in the 19th Century, since then they have been enlarged and repaired on numerous occasions.
It’s a bit like an estimate on a vintage car, you don’t know what your going to find till you get into the hidden sub-structure. The big difference is the rebuild has to be too a far higher standard than the original and pass its Nuclear certification.
I’ll take that! 👍
I seem to remember earth quake prodding being a major issue for these docks for nuclear certification. Again I am guessing that not a big issue for floating docks.
Jim
Honestly sometimes you do my head in, but you absolutely don’t deserve the comments made by David Lloyd no one does (😡).
I’ll try and explain why and just bear in mind I’m not a civil engineer, but I have watched a few buildings being constructed in my time and asked a few dumb questions (🤷🏻), thankfully I always got a civil answer.
If you were talking about just a standard SSK I’d say yes a floating dock would be fine. But not for Nuclear the simple reason is stability be that seismic or otherwise (which you can mitigate due to geological location and very careful construction). FYI for those that bleat on about saving money by buying AIP SSKs just remember that refuelling them isn’t exactly a straight forward or safe exercise due to the substances used (HTP and LOX).
Certain tasks cannot be carried out in floating Drydock as Err they Mmm float so subject to tides, waves and Storms and you need absolute stability throughout the process or as much as can possibly be achieved. An example is the floating jetty up at Faslane it just looks like any other but it’s actually supported on piles that go right down into the bedrock which is Granite.
Replenishing SLBM / Warheads is one such task and anything that involves work in the reactor compartment, LOP(R), de fuelling or scrapping are some of the others.
Same goes for just about anything in the supply chain involving HEU, right the way back to manufacturing the fuel pellets everything has to be as stable as hell and massively controlled !
For instance if you want a large warehouse to store just about anything you just put down a large thick concrete base that can take the weight and build a pre fab on top. But build one anywhere in the DNE its got to be way thicker, steel reinforced and supported on piles that are actually driven into the bedrock rather that just thumped in.
I hope that answers your conundrum !
Good post. I don’t understand based on the above why we are looking at buying 3 floating docks ?
Easy Answer it’s for the jobs you don’t need to carry out in a fully shock proof Nuclear certified Drydock! All ships including Subs have to undergo a mandatory periodic hull inspection and seaworthiness recertification. Then there are minor hull repairs, replacing Acoustic Tiles and just like every thing that floats they need to have their bottoms cleaned !
Floating docks up at Faslane mean this can all be done locally, the crew can be accommodated in the dock itself and it cuts down the time taken so increases availability.
Bottom line is having a single aging lift is a single point of failure and with the other docks all occupied you end up with boats you just can’t move or use.
I have said before that 3 does seem a little excessive just for Faslane, so and this is pure speculation but I wouldn’t be surprised if one ended up way down South when we start to deploy an Astute in Australia.
Bloody stupid thing is we built a floating Drydock in the 60’s for precisely this purpose (AFD61) for the R class so perfectly big enough for an Astute, then when the lift was built we sold it to Iceland (it’s still in use).
Thanks for the reply, I keep seeing comments on Navy Lookout and there seems to a difference of opinion on them. They have to being built for something
Davenport will be essential when Labor allows Scotish independence!
Didn’t they make beer !
I don’t recall labour even offering them a referendum on it! 🤡