Responsibility for protecting Britain against losing satellite services is split across government with no one bringing it together, Katie Barnes, Executive Director of the National Preparedness Commission, has told Parliament’s Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy.
Asked how adequate current governance was, Barnes said: “From a resilience perspective, the model that is in place is of a lead government department owning different risks and different CNI sectors. That is inadequate in this kind of scenario, because the services are used across so many different CNI sectors, and so what is missing is the co-ordination and coherence piece.”
She said the issue barely featured in the government’s resilience action plan and that the national risk register only covered positioning, navigation and timing, adding: “I would be tempted to ask: what would happen if that capability were taken away, rather than if that particular risk materialised?” She called for a Cabinet-level post responsible solely for resilience, as the House of Lords National Resilience Committee recommended in a report published the same day.
Baroness Tyler of Enfield said the Strategic Defence Review had called for a reinvigorated Cabinet sub-committee on space, but that the latest list did not include one and the space minister does not sit on the National Security Council. Lee Willcox-Jones of the Satellite Applications Catapult said a National Audit Office audit in March had found “confusion between departments and no agreed resilience levels” on space weather, which he said was evidence for a central cohering function.
The committee was told that 18% of the UK economy depends on satellite services. Major General Paul Tedman, the former commander of UK Space Command, told a later panel that disrupting the timing signal alone would cost the economy around £1 billion a day, and that “I think there were three Secretaries of State associated with the UK space strategy, but who is actually in charge?”
The Lords committee recommended a Cabinet minister solely responsible for resilience within six months, supported by a Chief Resilience Officer at permanent secretary level, ITV News reported.





