Scotland’s state-owned ferry agency is now “openly hostile to Scotland’s shipbuilding industry”, Scottish Labour’s Paul Sweeney has said, after its chief executive told MSPs he is “100%” against giving two small ferries to the Ferguson Marine yard.

Kevin Hobbs, chief executive of Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited, told Holyrood’s transport committee that he and CMAL’s board opposed the move, despite a pledge by Scottish ministers in March, and would have to be instructed to make the award by ministers, who are CMAL’s sole shareholder. He said: “While we want to see that shipyard survive, we do not believe building ferries there is the right thing to do for the island communities.” He added: “Commercially I don’t believe, we do not believe as a board, that we ought to to be building ferries there.”

Hobbs said he wanted the yard, a few minutes’ walk from CMAL’s offices in Port Glasgow, to continue, but was worried that the delays and poor value for money seen on MV Glen Sannox and MV Glen Rosa could be repeated. A letter from Hobbs to Transport Scotland describes direct award of the new small vessels as “problematic at best and folly at worst”.

Sweeney, Scottish Labour’s Shadow Transport Secretary, said: “Mr Hobbs’ remarks reveal that CMAL is now openly hostile to Scotland’s shipbuilding industry, a position that is completely untenable and unsustainable for a publicly owned body.

“It is unacceptable that CMAL has awarded nearly half a billion pounds of Scottish state shipbuilding orders to foreign state-backed shipyards in Turkey, Poland and China, actively undermining the national mission to rebuild and develop Scotland’s shipbuilding industry that Labour is pursuing.

“CMAL needs to get over its hang-ups about the flawed Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa project, that it was at least partly responsible for, and join the national mission to revitalise Scottish shipbuilding in a coherent way, rather than sending a chill down the spine of the remaining shipbuilding workforce in Port Glasgow.

“The Scottish Government must urgently update its outdated procurement rules to stop CMAL from undermining this strategic industry, and implement in full the recommendations of the UK National Shipbuilding Strategy, particularly on proper social value weightings in public procurement.

“Ministers must immediately proceed with the direct award of both Phase 2 of the Small Vessel Replacement Programme and the Marine Directorate’s fisheries protection and research vessels to Ferguson Marine Port Glasgow. The skilled workers at the shipyard have been let down for years by reactive and half-baked SNP policies on shipbuilding, it is time to back them with real orders, not risk further industrial vandalism.”

Martin McCluskey, the Labour MP for Inverclyde and Renfrewshire West, said: “It is extraordinary that a Scottish Government-owned body is actively arguing against contracts that could secure the future of another Scottish Government-owned company.

“The workers at Ferguson Marine deserve better than to be caught in the middle of disagreements between different arms of the Scottish Government.

“Nor should the interests of island communities and shipbuilding jobs in Inverclyde be pitted against each other.

“We have heard repeated promises from Scottish Ministers about securing the future of the yard, but what we need now is action, not more warm words.

“The Scottish Government must urgently move to a direct award as they promised and give the workforce the certainty they desperately need.”

Stephen Flynn, Cabinet Secretary for Transport, told the same committee session that the government remained committed to the direct award. “I believe it is absolutely right that we put our confidence in Ferguson’s as the last commercial shipbuilder on the Clyde to be able to deliver these vessels for the island communities to ensure that we have resilience within the network, the resilience that they deserve,” he said.

CMAL has not awarded a shipbuilding contract to a Scottish or UK yard since 2015, placing orders with firms in Turkey, Poland and China. The second of four ferries being built in Turkey, MV Loch Indaal, was handed over to CMAL on Wednesday, and the UK Defence Journal has previously reported that ministers approved extra funding to complete the island ferries at Ferguson. Sweeney has long campaigned on Scottish shipbuilding, and has set out his own proposals for the industry.

George Allison
George Allison is the founder and editor of the UK Defence Journal. He holds a degree in Cyber Security from Glasgow Caledonian University and specialises in naval and cyber security topics. George has appeared on national radio and television to provide commentary on defence and security issues. Twitter: @geoallison

1 COMMENT

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here