The UK Defence Journal has been using the same comment system for five years now, it’s time to change that.

As part of our redesign and refresh at the New Year, we looked at getting a new comment section for the website. That objective can now be ticked off.

The biggest complaints we’ve had over the comments section on this website is that the commenting feature is simply clunky. The system doesn’t notify users when people respond to their comments, it doesn’t allow people to edit their comments and in general makes it a pain to follow replies.

Despite this shambles, a very active and knowledgeable community of commentators has formed on the UK Defence Journal.

As the editor and owner of this website, I personally enjoy reading the comments in response to my articles, since I don’t get paid for writing it’s a nice way to get something back for the work.

I think the people commenting here that have persevered through one of the clumsiest comment sections on the internet deserve better so, we’ve been looking at ways to put something better in place.

Our new system will be based around these points:

  • Clean, simple and easy user interface and user experience.
  • Live updates of new comments with notifier buttons to notify you of new posts on an article or if you prefer, when someone replies to your comment.
  • Comment voting, you can now vote good comments up and bad comments can be voted down.
  • Comment list sorting by newest, oldest and most voted comments.
  • Anonymous comments can still be posted if you prefer. (name and email are to be be set as not required)
  • Full integration with Social Network Login plugins (Facebook, Twitter…) if you prefer to use those.
  • Users and guests can edit their comments (time-frame to be determined).
  • Long comment text breaking function (a ‘Read more’ button).
  • Secure and Anti-Spam features will not allow spammers to comment.
  • Post sharing options through Facebook, Twitter, etc.
  • A feature highlighting new comments since last visit with different background.
  • Notification to a comment author telling them when their comment is approved.
  • Other ‘Quality of Life’ improvements compared to the original system.

Comments are moderated to check they comply with UK Defence Journal social media guidelines. If comments don’t comply they will not be published.

To learn about our social media and comment moderation policy, then click here, you can also now flag comments you think are abusive just by clicking the little flag near the top right.

I sincerely hope it’s a better user experience for all of you and if there are any issues, please e-mail me directly at [email protected]

75
Leave a Reply

avatar
37 Comment threads
38 Thread replies
40 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
38 Comment authors
andy reevesRashed MiahMalcolm WhitlockGeorge AllisonGerry Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest
Notify of
Daniele Mandelli
Guest

Thank you George.

I was quite happy with the set up myself. These changes will take some getting used to, and no doubt will make an excellent site even better.

Lusty
Guest

Agreed. Might take a little time to adjust, but it’s needed.

Ian Smith
Guest
Ian Smith

Daily reading for me, not least your well informed contributors. Whatever the changes, I’m in. Thanks for the site George.

Pacman27
Guest
Pacman27

Agree with Daniele, but good to have a refresh every now and again

Trevor
Guest
Trevor

Ah…! If only I could get a refresh every now and then…

PS… The new layout looks good. Let’s have some meaty content.

Lewis
Guest
Lewis

A welcome addition. It will be good seeing the comments ordered by like/dislike ratio rather than simply whichever one was added first.

Keithdwat
Guest
Keithdwat

Fantastic, it’s a bit different but much improved, thank George, the like and dislike buttons is a massive improvement

Keithdwat
Guest
Keithdwat

I just noticed as well you can see how many people are reading the comments at the top right!

Andy
Guest
Andy

Well done, a great feature.

Thatsapaddling
Guest
Thatsapaddling

Brilliant thanks for this update.

TwinTiger
Guest
TwinTiger

Happy to give this a crack to see the difference.

EDIT: This is my edit – thanks for adding this function if only to be able to correct my horrendous spelling

Andy P
Guest
Andy P

Hi, been reading the articles on here for a while and have tried to comment a few times with no success. Probably me being stoopid right enough. Good luck with it, I enjoy the articles.

Andy

Matt
Guest
Matt

As a web developer, I’m happy to see the UK Defence Journal keeping pace with the best of them. Give it a few weeks and we’ll have all forgotten about the archaic comments section of yesterday. Good job on the update George
[email protected]

BB85
Guest
BB85

Great job, the comments sections looks slick.

Nick C
Guest
Nick C

The old method was getting a bit clunky! Trouble is I will now need to learn how to use it and at my age…..?
Did anyone see yesterday’s article about the Russians having to scrap their ancient carrier, since the drydock failed they can’t put it anywhere else to fix it!

Rob
Guest
Rob

It has done them a favour then. Waste of money and frees up a tug to escort another ship!

Rob
Guest
Rob

Great stuff. Can we vote to have the baddies names in red rather than green? You know who you are! 🙂

Keithdwat
Guest
Keithdwat

By the amount of dislikes you have does that make you the baddie?

Rob
Guest
Rob

I’m happy to wear that. Can’t say I think the voting thing is a good idea though, rather shuts down debate if a load of people vote a particular way early on.

spyintheskyuk
Guest
spyintheskyuk

Someone doesn’t like you I think Rob, 2 more thumbs down.

I do find elsewhere that once the initial ‘new toy’ aspect wears off it works quite well though some use a star system instead which I suppose is a little less obvious in terms of pos/neg though equally for that very reason more frustrating at times in terms of it being less obvious the general number/view of those who click it.

Rob
Guest
Rob

It appears some people have no sense of humour, I tried to dislike my own comment too but alas you cannot vote on your own.

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

You don’t Say !!!!! This place Is almost totally devoid of humour now.
Bring back RGR I say.

andy reeves
Guest
andy reeves

baffled(as usual).perhaps my diminished mental capacity is clouding my judgement .since i don’t actually know anything about posters on the site, i don’t tend to notice the name of the posters, i enjoy them all but i wissh george would ban the use of acronyms which unless explained often leave me totally lost NO ACRONYMS PLEASE. RGR? IS THAT AN AIRCRAFT?

Julian
Guest
Julian

George has mentioned in another comment here that he might turn off voting if it doesn’t pan out. I share your scepticism although I can see how, together with the ability we now have to sort posts by “most voted” (assuming that means most positively voted), it allows something like a very informative Gunbuster or similar expert post to be easily spotted. I do think this post of Rob’s illustrates one of the pitfalls though. I don’t know how much flexibility George has with the new system but I wonder whether one half-way house to keep the benefit above might… Read more »

Rob
Guest
Rob

Very sensible suggestion. I mean its not like I came on here and said we should get rid of the CASD and most of the navy and just have patrol ships, unlike someone else I could mention, who will no doubt receive a lot of thumbs down!

I enjoy reading the posts as there are some very informative commentators on here so the thumbs up addition is a positive attribute, just voting down for the sake of it is not.

andy reeves
Guest
andy reeves

I HOPE PEOPLE WON’T TURN THIS INTO PERSONAL ISSUES I.E i don’t like this persons votes so i’ll minus all he/she posts maybe + or – votes are not really needed.

spyintheskyuk
Guest
spyintheskyuk

Doesn’t that mean we are all Baddies? well apart from one name I did see in red. Like the idea mind.

andy reeves
Guest
andy reeves

i’d like an option to post a new thread maybe something like plain, or normal digestives on the M.O.D coffee table scandal, that could spark a good debate

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

Hello Rob, It looks like you have Attracted a whole load of Trolls. Don’t take It personally mate, It’s entirely normal nowadays for the “New Age Offended” to hide behind their Keyboards and feel all Powerful like.

Trust me mate, I have first hand experience.

Nigel Collins
Guest
Nigel Collins

Many thanks George,
Hope you get well soon!

David
Guest
David

I used Simplemachines and it worked great. https://simplemachines.org/

bazjak
Guest
bazjak

Looking good

Steve Martin
Guest
Steve Martin

Excellent work! Doesn’t seem to want to connect to my facebook though 🙂

Rfn_Weston
Guest
Rfn_Weston

Looking good!

Expat
Guest
Expat

Nice 🙂

Expat
Guest
Expat

Great improvement, although the voting for comments can create a bit of a herd mentality and can put people off counter arguing the comment.

Cam
Guest
Cam

Nice one George?

Andrew
Guest
Andrew

Time to adjust but a good idea, esp for notifications to replies etc

Julian
Guest
Julian

Nice one George. I think you ticked every single one of the boxes with your list of extra features added. It must have been quite a lot of extra unpaid effort getting this up and running so thank you for that. Like many, I find the comments section hugely valuable. I do agree with Expat’s comment that sometimes having a voting system can create a bit of a herd mentality that can distort how people post because they, sometimes even subconsciously, start posting for up votes. With due acknowledgement of the irony involved I’m about to go and up-vote Expat’s… Read more »

JohnG
Guest

Looks great, good job George.

spyintheskyuk
Guest
spyintheskyuk

Wow does this mean I don’t have to fill in all the details each time… oh apparently no change there from what I can see. Certainly looks and behaves much nicer mind so thumbs up on that one. Much improved visually and functionally.

spyintheskyuk
Guest
spyintheskyuk

I apologise after the first one auto fill does work, so its a gold medal from me now folks.

Steve Taylor
Guest
Steve Taylor

Good.

Helions
Guest
Helions

Harumph! This is DIFFERENT! That is all… 😀

Cheers!

Alan Garner
Guest
Alan Garner

Can I actually post comments now?…..YES!

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

Hello George, Nice to see this new format. Thought I’d add my two Penneth worth, so to speak. It’s great to see the new features and Upvote feature but the Downvote one will cause Trouble. As mentioned Yesterday, I have 6 such Forums, (Set up and Moderated by a few like minded Ex Forces Vet’s both Fit and living with the aftermath of some Injury ) Defence related and otherwise, the Downvote feature just causes Grief and I personally do not include It as an Option. This particular Site (which I Love) has a real need for a Troll Deletion… Read more »

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

See, there is the first downvote. You have to be some serious Troll or Mentally sick Individual to downvote my post there.

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

Just like the sick reply to RGR when he replied a few days ago.

Sole mate, You’re good at reposting comments from previous posts, can you re post RGR’s Peadophile one please. You know the one, When He was Ridiculed by Herodotus for daring to post his experience.

Called him a Liar too.

Trolling of the finest order.

SoleSurvivor
Guest
SoleSurvivor

I’m genuinely not bothered mate, you have come on here tonight with a bee in your bonnet, you have targeted me on two articles calling me out. The above comment from Rob has downvotes, so you’re complaining saying its a bunch of trolls, or perhaps it might just have something to do with the fact someone got banned last night, the admin has stepped in, got abused for his troubles, created a new comments sections, I’m sure i was not the only one when this kind of felt like a fresh start, and after a host of nice comments Rob… Read more »

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

It’s not all about you Bud, Get Over yourself . See You.

Rob
Guest
Rob

I honestly had no idea there had been any problems or someone got banned. I didn’t understand why I was getting down votes but now I do. Sorry to anyone who got offended.

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

Rob, There are some pretty sad individuals on here. I Upvoted you once so that possibly leaves another 9 that felt the urge to Downvote you for some unknown and Bizarre reason.

Funny thing Is, You attracted more Downvotes than me and I’m currently Public Enemy Number One here.

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

Example shown below.

Daniele Mandelli
Guest

Nice one Captain. Very well said. As for voting I cannot do anything as it says I must be “logged on”

And yes you did mention the double ID’s way back.

andy reeves
Guest
andy reeves

ditto i’m without an arm and a leg.keep on posting, that’s why we’re all here.

Chris H
Guest
Chris H

While I no longer contribute to comments UKDJ is basic reading (including comments) given my history and interests in matter military. I think George & Co do an excellent job and these changes are a very good step forward. Well done UKDJ!

If people think they can do better well they can fire up a website and we can all have a read.

IMHO having seen how the ‘like / dislike’ thing works on BBC HYS comments I would maybe just quietly remove it. Just an opinion.

Captain P Wash
Guest
Captain P Wash

Why did you Leave ?

Rob
Guest
Rob

Apologies if my comments earlier came across as crass but I honestly had no idea there had been problems and someone got banned. My comments were not a reference to anything or anyone in particular, just a silly suggestion that’s all.

dadsarmy
Guest
dadsarmy

I thought the old system was fine too, but let’s try this new one!

Mmm, edit works 🙂

Gerry
Guest
Gerry

I’m surprised it took you so long George. Upgraded comments on WordPress have been around a long time. Added it to a site I run quite a while ago,

Malcolm Whitlock
Guest
Malcolm Whitlock

Pleased with the progress and the content of your site.

Rashed Miah
Guest

Thanks for the post. Very informative.

Rashed Miah
Guest

Excellent Post!

andy reeves
Guest
andy reeves

excellent, and behalf of all of the site users, thanks for all your great work, and control of the site, good luck with the new setup.