Civilian institutions are likely to have to support military operations in a major conflict, but the arrangements for doing so are not sufficiently defined or tested, the House of Lords National Resilience Committee has warned, according to its report.
The committee concluded: “The Government is right to rebuild its home defence arrangements, but the relationship between civilian resilience and military defence remains underdeveloped. In a major conflict, civilian institutions are likely to have to support military operations while maintaining essential services, yet the responsibilities and arrangements involved are not sufficiently defined or tested.”
It recommended: “We recommend that the Government use the Home Defence Programme to define how civilian and military preparedness will work together in practice. It should clarify the roles of government, local responders, critical infrastructure operators and other civilian partners in supporting defence and test these arrangements through regular training and cross-government exercises.”
Paddy McGuinness, the former Deputy National Security Adviser, told the committee that military aid to the civil authorities currently assumes support flows one way, and that in a conflict “the civilian authorities will have to support the military”, as they did in the Second World War. Lieutenant General Sir Charles Collins said a Finnish-style total defence model was not something the government was pursuing, though there was scope for a broader form of voluntary reserve service.
The committee also recommended that the government and Armed Forces “step up the plans to expand the Armed Forces ‘Gap Year’ Foundation Scheme with a vigorous public information campaign including targeting all those who are currently not in education, employment or training.” The Army intended to begin the scheme, modelled on Australia’s, in September 2026, with £13 million allocated for the pilot, the report said.
Defence ministers said this week that the Home Defence Programme and a Defence Readiness Bill, giving the government powers to respond to escalation towards war, are in development, with the bill to be brought forward before the end of this Parliament.











