Two of the five Astute class submarines should be fully deployable and operational at all times, one patrolling northern waters or the Channel and a second working alongside the deterrent patrol, according to a briefing paper published by the 878 Institute.
The recommendation appears in the first of a planned series on the condition of the Royal Navy. It reads: “To ensure that two of the five Astute-class submarines are fully deployable and indeed operational at all times: one actively patrolling the North Sea, the Greenland-Iceland-UK (GIUK) Gap, or English Channel to deter increased Russian submarine activity around British waters; a second always patrolling alongside the CASD.”
It follows the paper’s account of the summer, which states: “Despite maintaining a fleet of five vessels, it was reported that not a single Astute-class submarine was operationally deployed through summer 2026, and that all five remained laid-up in British harbours. Only HMS Agamemnon (one of the two planned additions to the five in service) is at sea conducting trials.
“This is deeply concerning, given both the rise in Russian sub-surface activity around British waters, but perhaps more worrying because of the lack of available escorts for Britain’s nuclear deterrent.” The Ministry of Defence does not comment on submarine operations.
A linked recommendation asks for more money for the class, and warns of what follows without it. It reads: “To increase resource allocation for the troubled Astute-class submarines, all of which were in docks for a period from June 2026. Increased resources are needed to alleviate maintenance backlogs, industrial bottlenecks, and dockyard infrastructure limitations. Without this, the Astute-class must be said to be failing, and with it, Britain’s nuclear deterrent risks being left defenceless at sea or dependent upon allies for support, eroding the UK’s ‘sovereign’ nuclear deterrent.”
Setting a standing requirement of two boats available continuously would mean two fifths of the in-service class at sea at any moment. Sustaining that demands considerably more than two hulls, because the conventional planning assumption across submarine operating navies runs at roughly three boats for every one deployed, allowing for deep maintenance, work-up and crew training, so the recommendation implies six or seven available boats against a class of five with two more coming.
The Astute class carries two primary roles, hunting other submarines and protecting the Vanguard boats, and the paper describes both when it says the class exists for “anti-submarine warfare, as well as fleet protection for the nuclear-armed Vanguard-class.”
Devonport holds the only licence in Britain to refit nuclear submarines, and ministers told Parliament this week that the programme rebuilding the submarine berths there is being recovered after design difficulties, with construction still to start. The refit of HMS Vanguard at the same yard ran to seven and a half years against an original plan of three and a half.
Russian activity around British waters has risen, and the paper records that the Royal Navy spent twenty-one days in July alone monitoring Russian ships, and tracking operations rose twenty-five per cent on the previous year. The Defence Committee reported this month that availability among destroyers, frigates and attack submarines raises questions about whether Britain can meet its commitments in the High North, and that the department has accepted an anti-submarine warfare gap in northern waters.
The 878 Institute published a broader paper on British deterrence gaps in August, which UKDJ reported at the time.












Shouldn’t 1 be available to assist the QE’s when they depart?
Who are 878?
Big ask for a 5 boat fleet need another correct?
Professional walkng pencil and faux posho Jacob Rees-Mogg’s right wing think tank that is funded by a lot of US money including from Trumps European Nationalist slush fund. Because foreign interference in UK politics is fine if the colour, language and politics is ‘right’. 878 because the fashy Jeeves and Wooster impersonator has a fetish for some imagined saxon nationalism and old dates appeal to his US donors.
I despise Jacob Rees-Mogg as much as the next sensible person.
But clarity and honesty foremost.
There is evidence that 878 Research was earmarked for substantial American government funding, but I would distinguish between money offered, formally awarded and actually received.
Based on reporting available as of 2 November 2026.
Trump proposed US$7 million from the State Department.
There is no evidence that the US government grant formally awarded it.
There is no evidence that the US government actually transferred US$7 million to 878.
The proposal was abandoned after congressional scrutiny according to reporting in September.
They are American religious organisation, they seem to know nothing about anti submarine warfare.
We don’t escort ssbn’s with SSN’s 🤦♂️
Our modern strategy is to keep Russian SSN’s on the other side of the Bear Gap.
These guys are clowns.
While these are pretty much clueless clowns, regarding the SSN, in fact an SSN used to be allocated to cover the movement of an SSBN on its move to its patrol area. While not sitting in its wake, it was there, and this is what I think most people will presume this to mean.
Airborne,
Absolutely no personal knowledge, but at least theoretically possible another E-NATO submarine(s) have assumed this duty. There are both SSKs and SSNs patrolling the NA. Through allied maritime HQ coordination, orders dispatched for specific rendezvous time and location. Virtual certain NATO collectively lets boomers go unguarded. 🤔😉
Let us try that again: Virtually certain NATO does NOT let its boomers go unguarded. 🙄
Would be surprised if the UK let other countries submarines escort its SSBN’s…. I would have thought anything to do with SSNB movements would be extremely sensitive, with as few people as possible being in the loop…
Andrew,
Would agree w/ that proposition under normal circumstances, however the RN is at an historic nadir of capabilities at the present time. HMG/MoD/RN may have determined that needs must until RN SSN maintenance issues are resolved.
USN, MN, etc., SSNs and SSKs materialize at HMNB Clyde on a routine basis. A quid pro quo of resupply in exchange for guard duty would be a win-win proposition. No personal guarantee however, that represents reality. 🤔😉
Possible I suppose mate, where’s Deep when you need him to post!
Airborne,
Agree, true SMEs could/(should?) comment on this in a generic, non-classified manner. Casual opinions can easily be incorrect.
Jim displaying his bs again.
Jim, please try to jog on; even PARA has you down for bollards.
We do use an SSN to cover SSBN when the latter is leaving or entering Faslane. Most recently is was a French SSN that had to do it.
But no, not in a “classic escort”.
More than none
I like the idea of limitations of elements in the navy especially if you make one for limited b numbers that cannot be flaunted such as the strength of the royal navy should not fall below at least f25
ront line ships
It’s arguably pointless; definitions get changed, programmes get delayed, politicians lie or are just genuinely incorrect.
If you say the RN must have at least 25 “frontline” warships, define frontline. The definition could start out as just frigates and destroyers, but could rapidly be expanded to include submarines, carriers, drone vessels, even patrol ships on the “frontline” in keeping our territorial waters secure.
The gap between the reality of our SSN fleet and the ambition of AUKUS is so great that I’m surprised no one seems to be questioning whether it is realistic or affordable. I understand the logic that with an SSBN based deterrent, an SSN fleet may be needed in part to protect it.
But the main threats outlined by the think tank are close to home and could be countered by conventional submarines – cheaper to build and far easier to maintain. At present, we in effect have no operational submarines apart from SSBNs.
We should be gunning for three ‘deployable’ at all times, given we need to ship one off on a regular basis to Australia.
I’m sorry, who wrote this report?
‘Astute-class boats averaged 128 months to build; SSN-AUKUS are projected to take only 18 months each.’
It also entirely ignores the major pressure on our submarine fleet; deployments as part of SRF-West.
Basic misunderstandings and incorrect comparisons.
Not correct if I remember the delivery schedule is one every 28 months but that still means a much longer construction schedule. In reality the complete build time including components such as the reactors will be much longer and they should be starting construction soon.
I’m quoting the report, to point out where it is incorrect.
We want one SSN-AUKUS delivered every 18 months.
Going off Japan and South Korea who achieve that rate with 2 under construction at a time it beans from first part to entering sea trials a build time of 3 years.
And then we need to remember that they are just building 3000 tons diesel electric submarines instead of 10,000 ton of nuclear powered submarines so even if we were as good as building as those two countries it would still be an entirely unrealistic aim.
Jacob Rees-Moggs foreign funded nationalist think tank.
The chancellor is reported as saying this morning that three per cent by 2030 is a target, not a commitment. Don’t hold your breath guys.
Geoff the % is always a target, because you don’t know what x% actually is until the year after you spent it. So you set a figure based on it having a target of X%.. the conservatives had a 2% target but the actual figure bounced between 1.8% and 2.2% depending on what actually happend to the economy.
O.K. but in that case there a lot of people who need to stop claiming that the government “will” be spending 3% by 2030.
Yes but that’s the target, so essentially it’s ok to say that, as it was always stated we spent 2% even though some years we did not.. you never know they could end up spending 3.2% 🤷
Two to be at sea at all times? Not sure I keep coming up with a minimum of three to be either at sea or ready for sea at all times. One for distant escort to the SSBN, one of hunting up North and one for carrier escort.
I also have a further problem, the intent to build upto 12 SSN-AUKUS boats with payload modules. I am not sure if that is the correct way to go. A standard 4 VPM module is about 85 feet long, this includes the equipment space for the VPMs/missiles and an extra ballast tank. Reducing the Module to 2 VPMs will not reduce the overall length by much. I keep thinking that we need to design the future SSN with a forward Multi Mission Tube and no VPM Module and the same design without a MMT but a VPM module insert. This only works if HMG confirms the numbers of SSNs to be built. The swedes seem to have a Multi Mission Tube about 56 in in diameter that can launch ROVs, a full diver team etc.
The two versions would have two different operational functions. SSN with VPM would operate as CSG escort and Tactical Strike. The SSN with the MMT would act as SSBN Escort, hunter killer and special operations. With 12 possible boats then six of each version would be ideal.
Maybe might have been made easier if they had a small fleet of SSKs in the mix? Under ordering of Astutes. All a bit late and needed yesterday.
A hypothetical 12 boat fleet will require ‘hugely’ more resources to operate, maintain and upgrade.
Spending will need to pass 3.5% and head towards 4+% by 2040.
It will never happen under a socialist government, that’s for sure.
No really the capital cost for 7 or 12 boats will probably only vary by about 8-10 billion.. the on costs of management the fleet will exist again for a fleet of 7 or 12 boats so yes an increase but the facilities all need to be in place anyway.. and that 1% increase in defence budget as we go to 3.5 is about 35 billion every year in today’s money.. essentially 1 year’s increase will pay for the whole lost + on costs for the life of the SSNs with money to spare.
I take it the garage no longer goes to sea.
Can we have some context on future articles on where these ‘calls’ come from? If not it feels like an agenda is being pushed and I take this site less serious.
An American funded ‘think tank’ from the stable of Mogg is not really appropriate. The guy has done his best during his political career to return the UK to the 1950’s. Grey and broke.
Thanks to those who posted the context.
Its a defence related topic and conversation, so relevant according to George and his team. And while in your opinion Rees Mogg is wanting the 50s, this current crop of sad sacks in charge want us back to the “glorious” 70s, an era which was full of high unemployment, low output and productivity, high inflation, strikes, stagflation, three day weeks, 4 general elections, winter of discontent and an IMF bailout! Oh the 70s, such great times eh.
Assuming rule of 3 it would be reasonable to expect 2 boats operationally available given a fleet of 6. Since we only have 5 at this point, keeping 2 available is a bit of a stretch. There is an obvious difference between ‘operationally available’ and ‘at sea at all times’, so the article headline is a bit weird.
It’s poorly worded and coming from a questionable source, but the overall point is valid – we should be able to maintain 2 boats operational with the fleet we have planned, but at present we aren’t even sustaining 1.
The final T boat retiring last year should’ve been fit into the schedule the same way a boat going into deep maintenance would.
The underlying theme of this website over and over again is a manifest lack of resource allocated to national security.
‘Increased resources are needed to alleviate maintenance backlogs, industrial bottlenecks, and dockyard infrastructure limitations. Without this, the Astute-class must be said to be failing, and with it, Britain’s nuclear deterrent risks being left defenceless at sea.’
Yet plentiful resources are available but hopelessly misdirected.
Britain must rediscover the ability to build nuclear power on time and budget. The Climate Change Act 2008 must be repealed, removing the need to hit carbon budgets. That will free up well over £320 billion over the next decade for necessary defence spending.
The crazy thing is that the Climate Change Act was always a load of old nonsense and now threatens the national security that it was supposed to be safeguarding.
‘The IPCC, NASA, NOAA, and EPA state that essentially all of the observed rise in atmospheric CO2 since the pre-industrial era originates from fossil-fuel combustion. This paper shows that claim is mathematically inconsistent with the isotopic record those same agencies rely on…The claim of fossil dominance is therefore not merely empirically weak; it is inconsistent with the arithmetic of the isotopic constraint applied to the standard measurement record.’
‘Mathematical Falsification of the Fossil-Dominant Hypothesis for Rising Atmospheric CO2 Using the Keeling Relation’ Cohler et al. 21 Oct 2026