Three more Type 31 frigates, three more Type 26 frigates and four new shipyards should be funded through defence bonds and delivered by the mid-2030s to counter the threat from Russia, according to the Liberal Democrats.

The party published the proposal alongside polling it commissioned, which found that sixty per cent of people think the government is not doing enough to protect Britain’s critical infrastructure, including undersea cables, from Russian attack.

James MacCleary, the Liberal Democrat defence spokesperson, said: “After years of the Conservative Party underinvesting in our military, we are now dangerously exposed and woefully unprepared. Russia is actively, and brazenly, testing the limits of our naval defence capabilities – but Labour has dragged its feet on investing properly in our defence.

“We cannot afford to sit on our hands while Putin’s aggression intensifies and our national security weakens. We need a plan which gives confidence to British industry and allows our manufacturers to get on with delivering for Britain’s long-term security.

“By investing now in six new warships and by expanding our ship-building capacity with four new British shipyards, we can regenerate our fleet, protect our vital underwater infrastructure, and ensure Britain has the defence capabilities we need to stand up to the Kremlin.”

The party said it would raise the Digital Services Tax from two per cent to ten per cent and use part of the proceeds to cover crewing and maintenance. It acknowledged that no estimates exist for the in-service costs of either the Type 31 or the Type 26, despite parliamentary questions pressing the government for them, and extrapolated an assumed £20 million a year for each ship from 2018 estimates for the Type 23 and Type 45, giving £120 million a year for six ships in 2034/35 terms.

On the threat, the party cited the Royal Navy spending twenty five per cent more time monitoring Russian vessels around British waters, a Russian warship firing warning shots at a yacht off the Isle of Wight in June, and a Russian attack submarine and two intelligence submarines loitering over critical undersea cables in the North Atlantic for a month in May. It also raised Russian escorts for sanctions-busting tankers passing through the Channel.

The polling was carried out by Savanta, which interviewed 2,234 United Kingdom adults online between 29 May and 1 June this year, weighted to be representative by age, sex, region and social grade. Respondents were told that the head of the United Kingdom’s intelligence and security agency has warned of relentless attacks from Russia on critical infrastructure, and asked whether the government is doing enough to protect it. Five per cent said definitely, twenty two per cent probably, thirty nine per cent probably not and twenty one per cent definitely not, with fourteen per cent unsure. Concern ran highest among older respondents, at sixty seven per cent of those aged fifty five and over against fifty one per cent of those aged eighteen to thirty four.

The Defence Committee reported last week that dramatic progress is needed in building up British forces and ships for the High North, and the Liberal Democrats argued that the Strategic Defence Review set a compelling vision for the hybrid Navy while the Defence Investment Plan failed to provide the resources to rebuild the fleet.

Craig Langford
Trained as a mechanical engineer, Craig took an unconventional route into journalism, bringing with him a rare technical precision and analytical depth that continues to set his reporting apart.

16 COMMENTS

  1. All very well and we would all like more frigates to grow the fleet but I just don’t see where the money will be coming from unless it’s taken from the Army and the RAF that is. Personally I would be really happy to just see three additional T31 which would provide the necessary presence whilst still being relatively affordable – the T26 being just to costly IMHO fir many of the tasks that our frigates have to do. Three more T31 to make a class of eight would round the fleet up nicely and allow us to.oull back the two Batch 2 Rivers we have out east to replace the Batch 1’s in doing more basic constabulary duties closer to home. . 2 x T31 as a forward presence he Pacific and Indian oceans would provide a much more credible presence doing exactly the job they are designed to do although I have to say whilst a sceptic at first the two Rivers we currently have out there seem to be doing an excellent job.

    • To be honest I think the CCV is going to be an iterative build of the Type 31.

      Essentially a more focused AAW version. I suspect that is were the Australian radar will come in as a sweetener industrial offset for all the nuclear power plants and other components we will be building for their SSNs.

      So essentially CCV as a AAW T31 Batch 2 ( remembering the T31s mummy was an AAW frigate). Use up its mission bay as a drone ship command and control facility and it’s got the boat bays and flight deck to act as a good autonomous ship mother..

      Build 6 in the early to mid 2030s then build another 6 in the late 2030s early 2040s. That’s Babcock used up till 2045/6
      Then get BAE to build a batch 2 type 26 focused as a high end all round carrier escort, but with a CEAFAR radar and 48 Mk41 silos and 48 CAMM silos by removing the mission bays. Build 6 of those.. which would have BAE working till 2045

      In that end you then get a 2050 navy of
      5 T31s focused on overseas patrol, ASuW and strike. ( with its mission bay turned to autonomous vessel command and control facility). These will essentially command and guard an overseas autonomous group. South Atlantic, Middle East and far east.
      8 ASW Type 26s for high north and Atlantic ASW group leaders with there own flotillas of ASW autonomous vessels..
      12 CCVs AAW flotilla leaders and general Atlantic and high north dogs bodies.. one of these and a T26 would make a very robust high North Sea control squadron.
      6 Batch 2 T26.. the RN version of the Burke but with a greater ASW focus to match the threat environment.. essentially the carrier battle group core escorts.

      That would give you a balanced escort fleet of 31 ships in 2050.

      • That’s a good balance Jonathan, add to that the hybrid unmanned assets and you have a robust Navy.

        Possibly the biggest influence we can bring to bare is the SSN force, certain some of the 3.5% should push up the numbers, an ideal would be a 16 strong fleet with 10 operational boats.

        With the numbers built, AUKUS,s programme cost shouldn’t run out of control, after all it’s coming from a now experienced SSN/BN design and build team.

        Hopefully!!

        10 operational SSNs would represent an extremely capable force world wide. It would allow us to keep a pair on rotation in Australia too.

    • You could leave the B2s where they are and any T31s can be an added into whatever regions with their greater capabilities. The home based B1s can replaced with 3-4 more capable and cheaper coastal corvette/opv/AH120 types or additional T31s. The FI could have a Artic capable opv plus T31 in the loop. Something more capable than a B2.
      And maybe the addition of a fourth naval base up in NE Scotland (Edinburgh/Leith) for North Sea facing, rather than concentrating everything in the South and Faslane?
      Just to stir this old one up again. Would it be worthwhile giving the B2s a mild upgrade with a 40mm, newer radar, hangar?

      • Quentin, some good thoughts there – respect. A tad early to put together a considered reply , it’s 04.50 now for me insomniac that I am but however ! Of all the RN hulls we have put in the water in recent times the B2 Rivers just keep.on going and proving their worth. A tough sturdy hull , lean nanning thus cheap to run , good sea keeping and big enough for ocean passage at least, long endurance , what’s not to like. Oh yes except the fact for what we use them due their horribly under armed. I agree completely , IMHO a Bofors Mk 4 40mm a no brainer indeed. Would give you a CIWS capability plus counter drone , a decent ship stopper too. Shadow fleet interception etc etc . There are also many other options to beef up the arnament without adding massively to the crew . The new Konigsberg standard ISO NSM fit recently demonstrated comes to mind but I would also like something smaller, cheaper to counter USV . Sea Brimstone being the weapon of if choice , some great videos out there on YouTube demonstrating potential but like so much Brit kit shows massive potential but never comes to be. For me ideal weapons capability fit for a V2 would be Mk 4 Bofors up front , NSM ISO port side aft behind the crane, Peregrine ISO starboard aft and 2 x 8 Sea Brimstone at the stern end of the flight deck which would not restrict hello and UAS ops. I would also add 2 x RS4 RWS •50 HMG port and starboard of the bridge taken from surplus army RWS coming from Boxer we now won’t get. IMHO this would then give you a potent and capable Leander sized asset for use in the Baltic , Adriatic or poss even the Gulf. Falklands – defo. I would however still pull them back from the Pacific and replace them with 2 x T31 as soon as they are ready to come online. Just my thoughts !

        • Thanks Pongolo and the same back to you. Thats quite a list and a few levels up from me!
          I noticed a while back a NA group called ICE based on the Isle of Man who have a B2 lookalike “Thames” class 85m opv with/without a hangar that you might like to look at. There must be lots of Rivers upgrade options including recycling some T23s Artisan’s? But a few more T31s would seem good value with its base capabilities for the money. Five seems a very limited quantity. Hope they replace the 3 B1s with something useful.

    • The cost of ordering more T31 is peanuts @ £350m ea

      If they’d ordered more T26 at the time they would be £850m ea

      These will be spread over years of production.

      The silly bit is more shipyards rather than focus on training more workers to do that fiddly bits.

  2. They can promise anything they like, it’s easy when they know there is zero chance they will ever have to deliver on it!

    • In the end the job of the smaller parties is to push the agenda.. not ever being in power sort of allows the freedom to push.. it’s why I always liked and organised meaningful public consultations when I was looking at service redesign.. the professionals, managers and organisations bidding would all be looking at it from the angle of the people in power who had to deliver.. the public would just blue sky the hell out of it, and sometimes you got some good stuff you could use.

  3. Interesting to see the Lib Dems making defence pledges part of their manifesto. Maybe defence is climbing in public concerns.

  4. Seems rather Random with No Explanation..!
    And Certainly no idea of who would Mann these Vessels..?
    YET to see who would totally Mann the ones on Order..!

    • Details, details good Sir.

      As the fictional Sir Humphrey said, “government press releases aren’t delivered on oath”’

      Never mind minor parties’ ones!

    • Indeed, all three services have suffered excessive cuts to personnel, in order to try to fund the inadequate equipment procurement budget. We have got to the point where we have no mass at all and could not sustain a fight against a peer enemy for more than a couple of weeks.

      As defence spending rises to 3% then 3.5%, we really need to start increasing personnel numbers. I would think by17,000 –
      11,000 army (15%)
      3,000 RAF/RAF regiment (10%)
      3,000 RN/RFA (10%)

      Army larger, because it cannot currently fulfil its NATO commitments, due to heavy and muddled cuts over the last 14 years.

      I doubt there would be any real problem recruiting the numbers:.we get tens of thousands of applications, but only select a small proportion. This is not because the unsuccessful applicants are slall unfit, suffering from ADHD or anything, it is simply that the MOD man behind the curtain dials down the control button to keep the numbers down below authorised establishment levels to save money. The MOD has been playing that game for years, deliberately extending the lengthy application process so that a load of applicants give up and go into civvy jobs instead.

      That increase in regular trained troops needs to be matched by a sizeable increase in the number of volunteer reserve unis and numbers, which have deliberately been cut to the minimum to save money.

  5. We don’t anymore have the skilled workforce in sufficient numbers to build warships and armoured vehicles at pace. The.big increase.in apprentices is great for the future, but it will be a good few years before they become skilled and experienced employees.

    We could do to recruit a batch of experienced workers from Europe. Norwegians to supplement the T26 workforce, others from shipbuilding nations like Netherlands, Denmark, Germany or wherever has a surplus of skilled workers.

    The downside is that they generally earn a lot more than BAES and Babcock are prepared to or able to pay, Maybe the MOD.just has to bite the bullet here and accept some price rises on the frigates and armoured vehicles, as the alternative is a slow rate of delivery and less certainty about the quality of work.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here