Vladimir Putin will not succeed in his demand for Britain’s nuclear deterrent to be excluded from the defence of Europe, Lord Coaker, Minister of State at the Ministry of Defence, has told the House of Lords, saying disarmament would weaken NATO.

Responding to Lord Soames of Fletching, who asked what assessment had been made of unilateral nuclear disarmament, Lord Coaker said: “My Lords, I start by praising the service personnel and their families who sustain our deterrent. The Government assess that unilateral nuclear disarmament would remove the United Kingdom’s ultimate guarantee of security against the most extreme threats, weaken NATO’s overall deterrence posture and increase strategic risks to the UK and its allies. The only route to ridding the world of nuclear weapons is through gradual multilateral disarmament as the security situation allows. The UK will therefore maintain its independent nuclear deterrent for as long as the global security situation requires it.”

Lord Stirrup, the former Chief of the Defence Staff, asked whether Putin’s attempts to have the deterrent excluded from the defence of Europe were the clearest signal of its usefulness. Lord Coaker said: “The noble and gallant Lord is absolutely right to point out the situation as Putin would see it, but let it resound from this Chamber that he will not succeed in that demand. The UK’s, and France’s, deterrent is committed to NATO, although the operational decision remains with the British Prime Minister. Putin and those who seek to do our country harm should know that we have a strategic, independent nuclear deterrent that this Government will maintain, and I am sure future Governments will do so as well.”

Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle of the Green Party asked what assessment had been made of the risk of dependence on the US while President Trump was meeting President Putin. Lord Coaker said: “The Government would make a huge strategic error if they tried to push the United States away. It is important for us to understand that the United States, the UK and other allies standing together is of enormous importance to the security of our country and across the world. Of course it is an independent deterrent. The independence comes from the fact that it cannot be used without the express permission of the British Prime Minister.”

Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon said the Conservative benches fully aligned with the government’s commitment to the deterrent. Lt Gen Matthew Jones, Chief of Defence Intelligence, said in a speech on 20 November that Russia’s ballistic missile and nuclear forces continue to pose a substantial threat, and that his greatest fear is a significant Russian miscalculation.

George Allison
George Allison is the founder and editor of the UK Defence Journal. He holds a degree in Cyber Security from Glasgow Caledonian University and specialises in naval and cyber security topics. George has appeared on national radio and television to provide commentary on defence and security issues. Twitter: @geoallison

1 COMMENT

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here