The United Kingdom has offered to launch a major training operation for Ukrainian forces, with the potential to train up to 10,000 soldiers every 120 days.
The UK is no stranger to doing this, in 2015 the UK launched Operation Orbital which saw the UK train more than 22,000 Ukrainian personnel from 2015 until the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. The skills taught by British forces to Ukrainian troops during the seven-year programme enabled Ukrainian forces to launch a ferocious defence against Russia’s invasion.
The new programme would train forces outside of the country.
Mr President, Volodymyr,
It is good to be in Kyiv again. pic.twitter.com/wbpMuf6YqY
— Boris Johnson (@BorisJohnson) June 17, 2022
According to a statement:
“During a visit to Kyiv today, the Prime Minister told President Zelenskyy the UK could spearhead the landmark programme, which would fundamentally change the equation of the war, ensuring the Armed Forces of Ukraine have the resilience they need to be victorious in their fight for enduring peace.
The offer to President Zelenskyy came as the pair discussed the situation in Ukraine, and how the Ukrainian people continue to inspire the world with their incredible resistance.
The UK-led programme would train and drill the Armed Forces of Ukraine using battle-proven British Army expertise, allowing them to accelerate their deployment, rebuild their forces, and scale-up their resistance as they continue to defend their nation’s sovereignty against Russian invaders. International partners would be invited to host the programme, if the offer is accepted by Ukraine.”
Prime Minister Boris Johnson said:
“My visit today, in the depths of this war, is to send a clear and simple message to the Ukrainian people: the UK is with you, and we will be with you until you ultimately prevail. As Ukrainian soldiers fire UK missiles in defence of your nation’s sovereignty, they do so also in defence of the very freedoms we take for granted.
That is why I have offered President Zelenskyy a major new military training programme that could change the equation of this war –harnessing that most powerful of forces, the Ukrainian determination to win. Two months on from my last visit, the Ukrainian grit, determination and resilience is stronger than ever, and I know that unbreakable resolve will long outlive the vain ambitions of President Putin.”
It is understood that each soldier would spend three weeks on the training course, learning skills for the front line, as well as basic medical training, cyber-security and counter-explosive tactics.
Alongside the training offer, the leaders also discussed how the UK can play a pivotal role in ending the blockade of grain, say the UK Government.
The Government added that the UK has already pledged more than £1.3bn in economic and humanitarian support to Ukraine – including more than 5,000 NLAW anti-tank missiles, long-range multiple launch rocket systems, and artillery systems including 155mm Self Propelled Guns.
That 3 weeks mirrors roughtly what reservists have to undertake (Oh I used to be a PSI Permanent stressed instructor)
God don’t go there!!!
Foxtrot me, are there any soldiers able to be pulled off the line to be trained?
Bravo Sierra from a tosser of a PM.
Ukraine is our fight and we need to send the weapons the poor buggers need to fight it not this BS.
You are assuming that this is us forcing it on them rather than a request. If I was in the UKR Army and was asked what we needed I’d probably say ‘actually, if you could train our blokes to go to the front line that’ll enable me to release thousands of experienced NCOs to go forward.’
One thing the British Army is good at is training good quality soldiers with a limited budget, equipment and time. Also, we’ll get serious lessons from this about how to grow an Army that is combat capable, rapidly. One of the last jobs I did in the Army involved a study into how you grow the Army again when you need to or want to.
Yes I suspect this would be allied to the news that they are considering conscripting another 300,000 men into their army. From some of the stuff I have read too many Ukrainian and indeed foreign fighters are not getting this basic military training, vital if they aren’t to become cannon fodder. Surprised it wasn’t offered earlier considering the ongoing training we have provided since 2014.
Was assuming nothing. It’s been stated they lack the promised over reach of Western Arms. Simples.
Re read your post. Great post, thank you.
Actually believe this is a rational proposal. There is a general consensus in US military that the British military is a top tier organization in terms of personnel (approximately equal to US and Israel), but unfortunately often burdened by second class equipment and/or insufficient sticks of first class materiel. Believe the slogan was, “Lions led (occasionally) by Donkeys (and unfortunately too often equipped like beggars). Fortunately, there is eminently straightforward remedy for this situation–if it ever hits the fan in Europe or Indo-Pacific, simply arrange to deploy next to US units. Show up w/ appropriate requisition forms and the (supply) kingdom is yours. The Russians and Chinese have no clue re the amount of equipment the US military-industrial complex could produce given time and budget. There is a general dictum in the military that it is easier to ask forgiveness than permission; the worst that would happen is that it would be termed Lend-Lease Redux (or II), and we would ask for a lease extension on selected Carribean beachfront property . We could go 50/50 on the development of certain MWR facilities (aka exclusive resorts and condominium developments); everyone goes home fat, happy and contented. This could become the basis for a script for the sequel to “Catch-22.”
The US miltiary industry wouldnt be able to keep up with China. China has all the advantages, it has more natural resources, more people and way more active civilian factories that could be converted in time of war.
The only question is how effective is the Chinese gear. We have found out over the course of the last 30 years that US gear hasn’t been as effective as advertised when first deployed, but combat experience has mainly fixed this, for example look at patriot during gulf 1 Vs it’s current state. There is still a lot of stuff untested, for example the navy and it’s aircraft (against any form of area denial or air to air capability).
China is lacking the miltiary experience and lessons from it, even at a basic level like Russia got in Syria etc.
If we assume Chinas miltiary is less prepared than Russia and that it’s gear is equally ineffective, then the miltiary industry won’t be needed, as any war would be over before it can fully kick in.
Saying that China would have strength in mass, it could throw millions of troops at the problem, as mass consciption would be a lot easier in a communist country than a democracy.
The other movie I was trying to recall was the Clint Eastwood flick entitled “Kelly’s Heroes,” perhaps even more appropos.
A bit acid Barry, this appears to offer, possibly the best training available anywhere? Maybe we should judge Boris more on his Ukraine initiative than that bloody party gate, it’s a far better way to burn energy than carp on endlessly about issues that have in terms of law have been dealt with.
Nope. He is an appalling individual. Best rid of.
Absolute drivel from you. You have made clear your political preferences on many occasions
The politics comes from his grand standing and his chancing the optics for his own future. He and his followers are doomed in Cumbria and Tiverton will give the Cons the wake up call they need.
Your first sentence describes politicians of all parties and at all levels. “Grandstanding” is word people use when the particular politician spouting does not wear their favoured colour rosette
Johnson is an utter tosspot and does need to go.
But he’s absolutely right on this (not exactly hard, but eh).
And as a fellow Cumbrian, but already in a non-Conservative constituency (set to be merged into one – urghhh), you’ve taken your bloody time!
Sorry Tams.
And your contribution is?
On Ukraine I think he’s doing ok. How was Starmers curry with his 20 plus mates btw? And he’s not yet answered on the issue of mystery payments either I believe.
They’re all the same. I’d bet you within a few years a future Labour government will have ministers in the shit, just like this government and the last Labour one.
As always Farouk….HEAR HEAR!!!!
Add the brainwashing of students and unis by left wing teachers into that, they’re supposed to be impartial not partisan.
As I said in another thread, we’re really screwed.
Well said 👍
MUSIC TO MY EARS.😉
You wouldn’t last long on The Guardian Farouk.
Wear that as a badge of honour mate😂.
Their biased reporting is legendary imho. I got banned once after doing some follow up on one their articles saying that black people were being killed at an unrepresentively large rate in UK.
I tracked down the report ( it was by ONS – which the G didn’t give – which made be right off sus about their story).
Crunched some numbers. Yes G was right but didn’t say some things;
1. Most black murder victims were killed by black perpetrators ( well well…..)
2. Taking into account the relative size of black population to white population in UK …..white people were killed by black people at almost 100 times the rate as whites killing blacks.
Now how could The Guardian have missed that……exactly.
The enemy within.
Danielle, he has answered the police. Mystery payments, I have no idea – travelling 4 hours a day just to work a shift, so I’m totally knackered at the moment, sorry.
Cor! Take it easy mate. That is extreme!
Oh, but we do! Knackered from travel let alone the work, I’m standing for my local council.
Well said young man! I’m sure the majority of people in this country feel the same way, but, who cares what the majority think, certainly not the media! They didn’t give much coverage when the leader of the ‘British’ BLM was shot, at a gathering of BLM members in a drive-by shooting by, ironically, three black men! Oh, you couldn’t make it up!
The payment was a late filling issue and it was being donated to charity
So your plan is to send weapons to untrained Ukrainian soldiers ? SMH.
Simplistic. Trade training takes how long?
in my case 3 years lol
I’m probably being too cynical but just look at his body language in the pic patting Zalensky while smiling into the camera I think we can see what his priority is. Just thankful in this case it at least hints as doing the right thing and being on the right side, but I simply can’t doubt some of his motives in so doing I’m afraid. Again I hope I’m reading too much into the convenient pr effort.
2 + 2 = 64,464,756 methinks…
Do you think Zelensky cares what Boris’ motives are so long as he keeps supplying Ukraine with it needs? 🤷🏻♂️
I’d rather have Boris in charge than any of those EU leaders who drag their feet over sending weapons to Ukraine.
Agreed. Photo op.
As is every visit by any politician anywhere. You sa y you are standing for your local council, so will you not be trying to get local press coverage of your activities?
¿Que?
Is it really our fight David. There are several peoples of different ethnic origins in Ukraine but none of them are British.
Unless you know something that has not been made public. I cannot think of another reason for us to be so heavily involved, other that a payback for Russia assassinations on British territory. Do you remember what Boris said while he was Foreign Sec.
George, don’t you think the Budapest Memorandum might have something to do with it?
I think that went out of the window when ethnic Russians were being persecuted by Ukrainian nationalists. Both in and out of local/national government.
If memory serves, the Budapest Memorandum was primarily about nuclear weapons and disarming former soviet states. It mentioned nothing about removing the right of self determination from the various ethnic groups.
George, I think it’s a good idea to acknowledge the real reasons for the Russian violation of the treaty, and not be taken in by the fabricated pretexts.
Real reasons. Pray tell John, what would they be?
With references if possible.
Well, there are many contributing factors, but essentially it’s down to just one thing, which is that Russia has been taken over by an evil megalomaniac. I do wish that we could introduce mandatory annual mental health checks for all national leaders – indeed all politicians, in order to prevent this sort of thing in the future.
I’m certainly no fan of Putin, but he is just part of the problem. Something of a puppet for the real power in Russia and Ukraine for that matter, their very corrupt oligarchy. Including those in Ukraine that have direct and dubious links with Americas first family.
Mental health checks sound like a very good idea, long overdue. But in my humble opinion, anyone looking to make a career in politics, is precisely the type who should be banned from it for life. Failing the megalomaniac mental health test at the first hurdle. I would also add, that before they are eligible to stand for election. They need to have served a minimum of 5 years regular armed forces or ten years in the reserves. Which would not have excluded Putin but would have ensured his opposite numbers understood how to deal with him. It’s stretching the point calling KGB serving members of the armed forces but it’s all hypothetical and he was a colonel.
I note you have not dismissed the claims of persecution of ethnic Russians (and others) at the hands of Kiev Ukrainian nationalists. Obviously exaggerated by Putin in good old KGB fashion but not invented by him. See House of Commons early day motion linked here. https://edm.parliament.uk/early-day-motion/50927
There are other recorded accounts stretching back to well before 2014. Predictably, they are disappearing rapidly from the internet, as both sides ramp up the propaganda/censorship war.
I wish you well John.
It is totally our fight but we need SMEs in there not a clown like Johnson.
A Clown? Twice became London Mayor, then Leader of the Conservative party, then Prime Minister. How are YOU doing?
I’ve been casted for the master of clowns but someone beat me to it.
I disagree. We should be involved with finding a solution to the problem and preventing genocide. Ukraine is very similar to Yugoslavia, with the same tensions and likely outcomes.
The solution is Russia being completely pushed out of Ukraine, and ideally domestic upheaval there that sees Putina nd his cronies gone (hanging from lampposts or not I don’t care).
“Russia.” So, what about the majority ethnic Russians living in Luhansk and Donetsk Peoples Republics?
More ropes and lampposts or just camps and gas chambers.
BTW I appreciate your fully committed gung-ho approach.
In the perfect world I’d pay good money to watch the leaders of Ukraine and Russia fight to the death in the arena, winner takes all. The only weapons permitted being socks filled with sloppy dog turds.
There would be a negotiated peace within 24hrs of the declaration.
You need to read the lead-up to WW2….the parallels are obvious.
Gordon, I have studied that period of history extensively. Also the Cold War and afterwards. Both while in and out of uniform. I agree there are similarities.
WWII was a direct result of the treaty of Versailles and war reparations. The current Russia v Ukraine conflict, has it’s roots in the end of the Cold War and the collapse of the USSR. However, the devil is in the details.
I’d say the conflict actually goes back pre-WW1. As you say there are a lot of details and Mad Vlad seems to have cherry picked his own to justify his special operation
I’d agree, as nothing in history can ever be considered in isolation. As for cherry picking and spinning facts. That would be something every leader has done since our species was confined to Africa. It’s called politics.
Mad Vlad is as much a product of the Cold War as the current conflict. Col of KGB trained and moulded by the STASI of East Germany. Little wonder he is a vile human being who takes great pride in his past. Something quite common in that region given he is not the only former USSR piece on the board.
The similarities with the former Yugoslavia are there to be seen. More striking than those with the inter world war period and Germany. I propose that the solution is the same as Yugoslavia too. Partitioning along ethnic lines until they learn to get along with each other, in a generation or two. Not adding fuel to the fire with unlimited arms shipments as is currently the case. Maybe I’m wrong and should just accept that we have gotten off lightly. Considering what could have happened after the breakdown of the USSR.
Getting along with each other. Not exactly a strength of our species. H. sapiens sapiens. Regardless of how “wise” we claim to be.
There’s an interesting video on Youtube.
Apparently, the claim is that the Ukraine has huge gas reserves, bigger than Russia’s. That’s noteworthy.
However, Russia destabilising neighbouring countries is situation normal, but, should the Ukraine have these reserves this would reset the global order and Russia would be bereft of power. Not a bad thing.
And how exactly are they supposed to fight with weapons they’ve not been trained with? The old Soviet stocks round Europe are quickly running down and while the Ukrainians are doing good work these, they can do much better with modern NATO weapons.
The training is not about specific to arms.
It is basic training and I taught 6 STANAG courses in Slovakia to Slovak officers, each over three months – it is tough for all let alone you must add military training as well.
Then, cyber training… wtf is that about? Some of the best IT programmers are UKR.
Sean, this was a photo op.
The press weren’t allowed on the trip so the photos are taken by and released by 10 Downing Street. They will have sent out the photos that show Boris in the best possible light.
Boris went so fast to Ukraine as he needed to find out what the European leaders had said and to try and stay as the top Ukraine supporter.
Rubbish, you’re just letting your political bike for Boris warp your view of the world.
You honestly think Zelensky is going to take time out, from running a war, for a pointless photo opportunity for a foreign politician. This training is being provided because it’s been asked for the Ukraine. The Ukrainians haven’t been reticent about turning things down previously that they haven’t asked for or wanted.
The U.K. was previously providing training to the Ukrainian military pre-war through Operation Orbital and so is well placed to lead this this wartime training.
Unlike yourself I don’t presume to know the specifics of the training, but the Ukranians are transitioning from Soviet to NATO weapons which does mean some adaption and training. If you bother to look at CNN there’s an excellent piece following some retraining to use the M4.
It’s also worth pointing out that aside from the regions actually invaded, Ukraine has not mobilised its trained reservists who are still at home and awaiting call-up. The emphasis will be on getting these ready for the fight not civilians who have no military training whatsoever.
Ukraine has some good programmers, most countries do, nothing special though. But you clearly don’t understand that cyber security and computer programming are two completely different professions; it’s like confusing a pilot with an aircraft mechanic. I assume that you also fail to realise that the worst viral attack, NotPetya, originated in Ukraine. The U.K. has been providing cyber security expertise ever since.
“Rubbish, you’re just letting your political bike for Boris warp your view of the world.
You honestly think Zelensky is going to take time out, from running a war, for a pointless photo opportunity for a foreign politician.”
Conversely you are doing the same.
Zelensky is not running the war, he doesn’t have the skills. He is however an excellent front man that has shown from his activities over the past few months that he is up for any opportunity to video link into every meeting around the World that he can and glad hand any politician that can help his cause, especially of the status of Boris. He has proved to have been excellent in this role.
Your condemnation of Russias invasion and the atrocities carried out by its armed forces is still awaited. Can we expect this soon?
Not that I care what an apologist for war-crimes thinks but….
No I’m not. I think Boris is a deeply flawed character in both his private and public life. But he got two very important calls right:-
• pumping money into the development and production facilities for the Oxford AstraZeneca vaccine far in excess and way in advance of everyone else
• pumping weapons into Ukraine as soon it became obvious Putin was going to invade. Pretty much everyone else wanted until Putin’s tanks crossed the border.
I recognise that life is rarely black and white, except of course for Putin and his war criminal henchmen.
Zelensky is running the war in the same way that Churchill or any other national leader does, because ultimate responsibility lies with him. What he’s not doing is the Hitler-like micromanaging of tactics and operations that Putin did for most of the first 100 days. I assume after Russia’s failures in failing to take Kyiv and Kharkov and their humiliating retreats, the Russian General Staff have persuaded Putin to stop meddling. It’s astounding that Putin thought he could take Kyiv in 72 hours.
He has proven to be excellent and Putin has proved not to be! Well said troll boy! And now you are back any condemnation of Putins illegal invasion of Ukraine?
So please enlighten me as to who is running the war. And for gods sake don’t say Biden.
It is essential for Ukraine to keep the invasion at the top of everyone’s priorities so they can get what they need.
It only more countries would punish Russia for its actions. If putin invades another country that didn’t support the efforts to punish Russia I hope they don’t look the west’s way for help.
Balls in Russia court. It can withdraw to its own borders which aren’t and never have been under threat and the war would stop.
Well said.
Hows’ that statement condemning Putins invasion coming along Tankie?
Well said.
David, I’m assuming the type of training required mid war is somewhat different to peacetime NATO requirements. If we are taking sides and giving them SP90 etc. Some training will be necessary. The only advantage the Kiev Ukrainians have is the complex/advanced nature of the weapons we supply. Switching from old Red Army kit will take some time, even for the surviving experienced bilingual veterans. Not a job I would relish.
You’re not wrong.
Some good comments have arisen from this thread joust.
I never knew that their reservists had not been called up, if true. Taking them through training now by our and NATO partners could see them trained specific to arms and able to commit to the expected lull in the fight given the attrition on both sides, the Russians would be running on empty.
Please tell Airborne to put his green back on,they’ll need good trainers.
I remember the cold war ending dividend when lots of Russian speaking bods were lost; another capability gap, but, this country has bilingual nations and if not, I know for a fact that Latvia has many trilingual nationals; we need to harness everything we can.
With good will, hard work, and a commitment to return the borders of Ukraine back to her nation, I hope we smash the Russians and Putin gets the good news.
Ukraine is suffering huge casualties at the moment and while conscription age men have been prevented from leaving the country only a relatively small number of reservists with key skills have been called up, the rest have been told to stay at home and wait for the call or join the volunteers who are organised into home watch like cells.
Huge casualties on the other side also though. While Russia can only use the weapons it has and the older stuff in storage, Ukraine is getting newer, better suited weapons all the time. Russia only has its soldiers that aren’t the best trained while Ukraine will hopefully be able to get more of there new forces trained better. Only time will tell
Some obvious Qs here.
Will this be in Poland or the UK?
If in the UK, will this be through UK Trg Regiments?
If so what impact will this have on UK training?
3 months basic + 1 month special to arm?
Does this include officer & NCO training?
If other countries do the same then Ukraine will not only secure replacements for units already deployed but also be able to create new Bdes and even divisions.
Rob, reading between the lines I would say the choice of the word “Spearhead” says it all. UK instigates initial setup, NATO partners and future NATO partners help where they can. Could be a very useful exercise for all concerned, as long as it goes ahead with speed and not too much dithering by politicians looking for a phot op.
His words certainly suggested it would be in bordering countries as he said he was seeking partners in the program. Poland for the most part I suspect as they and Ukraine have very close historical links and already at the forefront of support. Will enable great support to the training too as tbh they would be amongst the most reliable and committed NATO fighting forces in a conflict with Russia.
Three weeks of basic training, cyber and first aid.
What a shame they cut the number of ATRs.
Is there even capacity to expand our phase 1 and 2 set up?
They were providing the same training mission until a few months ago.
Indeed why I can’t help but be a little cynical about this announcement and timing. At least by regurgitating existing or pre existing programs won’t do any harm and keeping up the noise of support is important. What are the 155mm artillery it states we are supplying? AS-90 I presume unless we are acting as middleman.
M109 withdrawn from Belgian service and sold to a Belgian arms dealer who was offering it on the international arms market. We bought it, refurbished it and now in process of delivering to Ukraine.
Yes, I was thinking regards putting them through phase 1 in the UK with our lot.
Thinking long term it’s possible that we can train the new toms to a certain level in order to get them forward and replace the more combat experienced blokes (and females) off the front line and develop them as JNCOs/SNCOs in compressed timeframe cadres! This war is long term now and we need to be planning for it mate!
Agreed.
I saw that Poland is over in South Korea having talks about getting kit. K2 main battle tanks, KS21 Ifv and the K9 artillery system.
I don’t know anything of those systems other than what I read here, but if they are that good and the price is good why not? The K9 looks like an M109 to my eye. I thought Poland were getting Abrahams? K2s as well???
For the artillery the polish use the K9 chassis with the AS90 braveheart turret with the nexter gun. The article said they could be looking to get more chassis’s to mount the current turret on or purchase the whole South Korean system.
The main battle tank is being called K2p I think. P standing for Poland. So could well be seeing an Abrams and K2p fleet. Very interesting.
I think the AFV is the 25t KF21 that the Koreans currently use. There was also talk of looking at the heavy 37t redback model that was offered to Australia.
It could all turn out to be nothing. I think the issue is getting some into service quickly so looking at how much capacity South Korea has to build/delivery vehicles and also looking at building in Poland.
The U.K. should really be doing orders quickly before other countries fill up order books. The K9 is needed. Give Ukraine the AS90. Should of ordered it 3 months ago. What variant who knows. K9 chassis with braveheart turret? Full K9 vehicle?
The AFV would next priority.
Seeing the 130mm new rhiemettal tank got me thinking about challenger upgrade. Should the U.K. get in early to get U.K. kit included?
Ha! 3 months ago.
They were waiting til 2028 I hear before 1st deliveries of FMFP! I’ve read it may be sped up slightly.
https://www.defensenews.com/land/2022/06/17/industry-deal-moves-poland-closer-to-acquiring-south-korean-artillery-system/
This is where I read it.
Hey Airborne, hope you’re holding up well after CGS kink-shamed your regiment.
😆
A few careers are now on hold for sure 😂👍! But they got away with it the last 29 times, quality Colchester ladeeeeee 🤮
And I can’t think of many Battalions taken off a long planned spearhead exercise just through banging a local lady. Although a few lads misbehaved on the last overseas ex and CGS has had enough! Just imagine the shit the Bde Commander must have given the CO 🤬😤💩. I remember a long long time ago something similar happened at Monty lines in the Shot, regular lady popped onto camp, however boyfriend in tow, short drunken while later the lads tried to launch him over the razor wire….didn’t end well for anyone 😂😇
Inagine the shit the Brig got!
Your Brig got an interview without coffee when NINE MP were put in The Cambridge over a weekend in the early nineties.
I’d say good drills to the lads in Colchester but more as a question… PARA being PARA.
In these times, we need 3 Bns of PARA with supporting arms, ready to go.
A fully equipped and supported Commando would be essential too.
Thoughts?
The worry is those experienced NCOs have been attrited.
Should this be a long term war, man management is an important facet.
Hopefully, the cadre can be developed and then create unit cohesion with inexperienced ‘Toms’ Airborne.
Agreed as Russia has reared its Nazi head in public and all free countries will need to be prepared for the long haul mate, for sure!
Just replied to an early comment, we need a Bde of PARA now, I know 1st are reassigned, 4 and 10 was/is AR, so choose a number, or bring back a Royal Irish Rangers Bn – we were warrier than you!
It’s a good start. In one of the other threads last week I was arguing we should have been doing something like this from day 1. Despite doing better than some other countries I think the UK has been doing far too little far too slowly.
Agreed this seems to be a vital commitment after the initial resistance prevailed so why only doing it now? Seems to be a mix of competing with other leaders. Is it’s yesterday combined with the fact we have little new physically we can now offer. So a sudden investment in training looks good shall we say in the circumstances I guess to show we are still doing our bit and keep the necessity in the news.
Watch and shoot, watch and shoot. It can be done.
Left out:
“Targets will fall when hit, carry on”
UNLOAD cock, hook and look.
I would like to know why we can’t, or seem reluctant to, supply Warriors or AS-90s. Yeah, they aren’t perfect, but better than the absolute nothing that Ukraine is getting from Germany despite asking for Leopards and Marders.
BJ sending more Rocket systems and 155 Artillery guns AS90s I guess.But do worry about our stocks going down .There again think that speaks volumes for us all 🙏
3 M270 and 20 2nd hand Belgian M109s,our stocks were already depleted I wouldn’t worry about them going down any further. Just send anything we have left and rebuild after.
Live and hope 👍
Can’t be AS90s, we haven’t sent any, Wallace ruled out doing so in this article:
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/apr/25/uk-military-aid-to-ukraine-could-rise-to-500m-mps-told
“Wallace indicated that the UK was looking at supplying Brimstone ground-based missiles that could be used to defend Odesa against any seaborne invasion, but he ruled out giving Kyiv the UK’s dated AS90 artillery”
Dated, my backside, still pretty modern by standards of half the stuff Russia has been using so would be pretty useful, Warrior too, maybe even offer an upgraded Challenger 1 or basic export variant of Challenger 2 considering we’re about to shelf most of them.
That’s right Christopher Wallace did rule it out ,however ,at the end of this Artcle BJ does mention sending 155mm guns which to me I can only think of AS90s don’t think we have any other type.🤔
I would like to an official source on that. The only Self-propelled artillery I have seen reported being used in Ukraine was donated by Norway. Not seen any AS-90s. I wonder if the government meant the 105mm L118 artillery.
The UK MOD has bought 20 M109 155mm SP guns from a Belgium arms dealer, refurbished them and is in the process of shipping them to Ukraine. Ukraine can already operate the guns as they have a Battalion of ex-Norwegian guns already in theatre.
Thanks for that update 👍
Its 20 M109 bought from a Belgian arms dealer and refurbished by UK.
Belgium at one point had just under a couple of hundred M109 mainly A2 the same as the 60’s vintage A2/A3 ones the UK withdrew and sold to Austria when it bought the AS-90. Belgium updated around a third of their total to the A4BE standard but have divested most of theirs over the last couple of decades to the secondary/scrap market, a lot picked up by Brazil and Indonesia.
BAE have upgraded many A4 to A5 by fitting a longer barrel increasing range, and larger engine along with targeting updates so some element of that may have been available as well.
Okay, thank you for the update. Has the gov provided an explanation as to why they couldn’t just take and upgrade the AS-90s we have wasting away in storage?
CAESAR from France as well
Careful Simon, most people on here hate the French nearly as much as they hate the Scottish.
So a great video on Youtube last night. It appears it is being put to very good use.
They just need more.
were are you planning on getting Challenger 1 from ? The only ones left are in Jordan
Boris should offer the same to Putin if Putin is willing to stop the war and go back to pre-2014 borders.😂
Boris looking after his election prospects again. No doubt a good idea but the Ukrainian soldiers defending Sievierordonetsk need tanks and artillery.
Which they are getting, it does not need to be us who supply them if we can offer other things too on top of the previous.
I’d rather BJ be looking after his election prospects by getting a bit of grandstanding in than be like the German and other leaders hiding and looking after their Russian fuel supplies or Macron who is more interested in offering olive branches to to a dictator like Putin but makes no such gesture to his allies in Britain.
Not in anything like the numbers required Daniele, or quickly enough. The only person Boris cares about is Boris
You could say that about just about every politician in existence.
Whether Boris is a self centred buffoon ( yes, he can be, and I support him on some things ) or not is irrelevant to what is on offer in this case adding to the earlier assistance.
Perhaps his detractors would rather he crawled into his box and let the EU leaders act like the big cheeses on Ukraine? I already know the answer. Earlier in the Ukraine crisis I recall a Finish politician was sniping at Britain’s contribution vs the EUs. They all do it, Macron was trying to be the big man earlier when he was visiting Putin. Politicians all jostle to be in the limelight all the way back to Caesar. And we are to find yet more fault in BJ for that? Not from me.
As for the lack of artillery or Tanks on offer, again, not relevant to the point I was making above or whether BJ is grandstanding or not. We can only offer so much. Blame the previous idiots in government for that from Major onwards, not BJ. He arrived as PM with the British Army equipped with 3 regiments of tanks and 3 of SP guns.
How many Tanks and guns have the rest of the EU or other world nations offered, like Spain, Italy, Germany, France?
What I can agree with you on is the urgency of need and the number, though I have read even the 6 MLRS from us and the US can make a difference if used correctly.
Actually I am Boris fan; he has made the ‘right’ call on a number of issues i.e. put pragmatism and people before money. This is the reason he is in trouble with his own party, for not following ‘conservative values’.
To maintain his credibility with his right wing he has to demonstrate he is a hard man on things like immigration and Brexit. Hence we put up with the xenophobic Patel and also why he has to make a prompt photo stop visit to Kyiv since the (evil empire) EU have just offered Ukraine EU membership candidate status. So we are in a competition for the affections of Ukraine. Zelensky is maturing into a capable politician 😉
Latvia closed her borders with immediate effect, employees worked from home at the beginning of February 2020.
Bluffer buffooned his way through the early months and 40,000 pensioners lost their lives as well as many more as the Convict differed over what to do, but, the airports remained open, and British people died.
“How many Tanks and guns have the rest of the EU or other world nations offered, like Spain, Italy, Germany, France?”
There is a pretty comprehensive list on Wiki on who has donated what. Also some country have donated cash to buy weapons rather than supply them. There has also been a number of requests from the MOD to industry about the ability to supply/source various items which may be partly related to this
Hi Simon. I know! My meaning was suggesting that those countries had assisted somewhat less than the UK materialy, despite the angst in some quarters over a BJ photo op.
Never mind the intelligence side through 5 eyes that as an anglosphere nation we are privy to, that would also be up shit creek the moment the SWP, Corbyn, Guardian BJ hating leftists get in.
The link to Wiki is useful one for other poster on here. I get the impression there are other on here (not you, I might add) who seem to be more interested in having a who can piss bigger comparison, rather then what the equipment is actually being used for in Ukraine.
The issue of Corbyn being prime minster and 5 eyes is an interesting one (not that he would have got in, as he was unelectable) You do have wonder how much prime minster/minster involvement in it there is (New Zealand for example being a top tier member). There are also the other tiers as well and what is shared with them.
Yes, there are Tier 2 and Tier 3, though what they are given will be minimal compared to the bilateral sharing between the Anglo nations.
Agreed a PMs involvement will be minimal day to day , although I’d read Thatcher was an avid devourer of intell.
It is Corbyn’s views that would have made the Americans take notice and threaten the relationship. What if he’d withdrawn us from NATO or told the US to vacate their UK locations?
Although he is no longer opposition leader it’s never far below the surface with that lot, which will always worry me. The anti NATO, anti AUKUS stances of Young Labour and the LP Membership are facts I’d love to see Starmer squirm over on live TV, as it flies in the face of the official Parliamentary LP position.
And that is why I consider Labour unelectable as far as national security is concerned until they move back to the centre like Blair.
As you will know, 5 Eyes, more properly called the UKUSA agreement, is primarily between the NSA and GCHQ. On NZs
Part they contribute the Waihopi station intercepting the Pacific Islands area, though with their links to China I’d read of concerns with data sharing.
Simon,
Your point about Corbyn is interesting regards his Marxist links. Today I’ve just read that the Teachers and NHS unions are looking at going on strike in line with the rail unions. What hasn’t been made public knowledge is that a large number of the RMT (As well as other union leaders) are openly Marxist , (Despite the huge salaries they receive) openly support the Russian invasion of the Ukraine, which has me thinking I could this be a plan of action by Moscow in which to remove the British Pro Ukr government from power and replace it with one which will end all support for the Ukraine by saying they (Like Macron) Moscow must be listened to , that they should be allowed to keep what they have stolen in the name of peace and that sending arms sends the wrong message and only hurts Ukrainian people.
food for thought or what.
Hi Farouk TBH as I said Corbyn was unelectable, my wife is a union rep and she said at the time he will never get in, he has his own little fan club, but there are lots of union members who will never vote for him. he had trouble with large groups of his own MP’s most of the time which is never a good sign.
I find it unlikely that we are look at some sort of general strike. The RMT are pretty militant and are not happy about the governments plans, but the rest of them are unlikely to join a general strike and again some of the views are out of step with there members. We do also live in a parliamentary democracy and I cant see that the major party’s being too happy to give ground to Russia. I have no doubt that Russian bot are in action on Facebook etc as some of the COVID/control type nuts are sharing all sorts rubbish on there (along with Flat Earth stuff!!) You probably got more issue with the “The Government is spending my money” types to be honest
It’s not good for Labour that they are equivocating about the rail unions and strike action.
It is complex but inflation is rocketing and people need more money, and yet, average £44k per year on the railway is damn decent money.
However, it was Thatcher who opened the tunnel and suddenly Brit drivers wanted parity with the French drivers, Major privatised the railways and drivers used the disjointed system to gain huge salaries.
Honestly, 4 hours travelling, 5 days a week, full shift, getting home around midnight, for min wage, I think they are on a good gigg and Labour should tell them to foxtrot oscar.
This is a total deflection and an own goal for Labour, the cons will milk it.
I’m in total agreement David. I’ve been a Signalman for 21 years and we have had lots if above inflation pay rises in that time. Drivers get even more. I see no justification for strike action myself.
Have you considered trying for a signalmans role yourself?
The Cumbrian Coast needs automation and subsequent loss of jobs, however, we also need higher line speed to enable far better connectivity to rest of the country.
Applied to clean trains overnight at Barrow – didn’t get a look in.
As a rail worker, and RMT member, I can confirm that is true.
And for people’s interest, not all of us railway workers are striking next week.
I myself see it as politically motivated.
Now, now. Some of us are nice 😉
That last paragraph is the first key.
One could wish for the systematic elimination of every RusAF Arty Regiment. Give the barstewards the good news and I wonder if they would fold like a pack of cards. EndEx.
Slava Ukraini mate. ✌
Daniele, EU are divesting themselves of reliance on Russian energy – about several years too late, after the cr@p Russia pulled on Latvia, but, it is happening.
Have a Youtube on what French CEASAR is delivering to Russian arms at the mo. 😉
US Grey Eagle sale to Ukraine has been ‘paused’ due to concerns over potential capture of advanced technology by the Russians.
https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/us-drone-sale-ukraine-hits-snag-sources-2022-06-17/
Any condemnation of Putins illegal invasion of Ukraine yet? Do you support illegal war, invasion, rape, murder, looting and torture? It would seem you do, very sad, but at least have the balls to confirm and defend your sad shitty opinion. Coward.
I think you are going to have a long wait TBH. you do have to wonder why he keep posting these articles on here as they are out of step with 99.9% of the posters on this group
Keep pressing!
Interesting that the excellent post from Farouk highlighting the hypocrisy of the Guardian/Left/BBC/others over BJ, Covid and much else has been flagged and removed.
It probably came too close to the truth for some…..
Good job I printed off a copy of it for use later if needed.
Is the British Army in danger of being over-stretched?
Only for the last 12 years once 8 deployable brigades have shrunk to 4.
It’s not just operational deployments that constitute commitment; add in the Permanently Committed Forces (PCF), training tasks, MACA/MACM and Public Duties.
In every area apart from PR spin! Decades of cuts do that.
Love or hate Boris at least he is actually helping Ukraine and committing for the long haul. Until recently France and Germany were selling kit to Russia, its nice to see they are sending a few things to Ukraine too. But the UK better follow the French president’s advice a humiliate poor old Russia…..
There is an interesting interview with the former head of the army, I think on times radio YouTube. In it, it was clear he was confused how it would be possible to deliver that level of training. If however they are able to deliver on it, then it’s great news, could make a significant difference, assuming it’s backup with weapons. I just hope not another one of boris unrealistic broken promises.
The article itself states previously trained 20k over 7 years.
Airborne is putting his lid on again, and him and Farouk will sort it in double quick time.
It is unclear to me what the details are. Is it Phase 1 training, Phase 2 training (if so, to what arms and services)? Is it training to JNCOs, SNCOs, WOs, Officers?
Is it training specific to equipment? Is it individual or collective training? Is it to be done in Poland, UK or somewhere else? Is it 10,000 doing a 120 day course, or 10,000 doing one or more shorter courses over that 120 days? Can Ukraine spare front-line soldiers to come out of the line for such training or is this training of new recruits or draftees or re-activated reservists?
I am not surprised the former head of the army is confused – so am I!