Defence spending should go to five per cent of gross domestic product immediately, the country should be prepared for a wider European war and planning should assume Britain may have to fight without the United States, according to a security academic at the University of Leicester.

Dr Simon Bennett, director of the Civil Safety and Security Unit in the university’s School of Business and author of a 2025 book on security lessons from the war in Ukraine, set out the argument in comments issued through the university press office.

Bennett said: “Given these facts, we must prepare ourselves to fight alone. Like Keir Starmer, Prime Minister Andy Burnham is in denial about Trump. The American president is a lost cause. Better to focus finite energies and budgets first, on supporting Ukraine, and secondly, on preparing this country for a wider European war. Defence spending must be increased to 5% of Gross Domestic Product immediately and, as suggested by former Secretary of State for Defence Lord Hutton of Furness in the 17 October edition of The i Paper, the British public must be told the truth about Russia’s hybrid warfare campaign.”

On the range of threats he believes the country is exposed to, Bennett said: “The United Kingdom faces a spectrum of threats. The country has suffered two Kremlin-initiated chemical warfare attacks, in London in 2006 (Polonium) and in Salisbury in 2018 (Novichok). The Council on Strategic Risks recently highlighted the UK’s vulnerability to biological weapons. Prime Minister Burnham, it is time to focus on what really matters – giving Ukraine the weapons it needs and securing a vulnerable United Kingdom. Do not prostrate yourself before Trump, as your predecessor did. As Volodymyr Zelensky and Mark Carney have shown, the only way to deal with Trump is to stand up to him.”

Bennett is asking for far more than the government has signed up to. Ministers have committed to NATO’s target of three and a half per cent of gross domestic product on core defence by 2035, with a further one and a half per cent on defence-related resilience and infrastructure making up the alliance’s headline five per cent figure. Bennett is calling for core defence spending itself to reach five per cent now, a distinction ministers have had to set out repeatedly.

Lord Hutton of Furness, whose intervention Bennett cites, was Secretary of State for Defence from 2008 to 2009. His argument that the public must be told the truth about Russian hybrid warfare runs close to what ministers have themselves begun saying. Wes Streeting told the Defence Committee this month that hybrid activity of this kind amounts to state backed terrorism, and Louise Sandher-Jones confirmed in a written answer last week that “we know Russia is conducting a campaign of hybrid attacks and sabotage across Europe.”

Ministers have also confirmed that government messaging on defence and security will build ahead of Exercise ALBISTON SHADOW and NATO’s crisis management exercise in spring 2027, and the Cabinet Office launched its Be Ready campaign this month asking households to prepare to look after themselves for three days.

The two chemical incidents Bennett refers to are the poisoning of Alexander Litvinenko with polonium-210 in London in 2006, which a public inquiry found was probably approved by the Russian president, and the Novichok attack on Sergei and Yulia Skripal in Salisbury in 2018, which killed Dawn Sturgess and which Britain attributed to the GRU. The Council on Strategic Risks is a Washington-based institute publishing on biological, climate and nuclear security.

Bennett’s case rests on his reading of the American president, whom he describes as a Russophile and, in his words and expressly as his opinion, a traitor to the West’s liberal-democratic values. He said he predicted in March 2025 that Trump would ally the United States with Russia through accords and treaties, and took criticism for saying so at the time.

George Allison
George Allison is the founder and editor of the UK Defence Journal. He holds a degree in Cyber Security from Glasgow Caledonian University and specialises in naval and cyber security topics. George has appeared on national radio and television to provide commentary on defence and security issues. Twitter: @geoallison

81 COMMENTS

  1. All logical and sensible but I can’t see us responding to such urgency fast enough if at all. But the more the message is pushed the better. And at least Europe generally is realising we cannot rely on either America or tech bros like Musk and urgently developing alternatives. This guy is even telling the US Govt (who provides 80% of his profits, arguably indirectly most of the rest indeed) that he won’t be able to launch their military space assets for much longer as he is discontinuing the Falcon 9, while Starship, even if he finally sorts it, can’t handle most of those military hardware. Imagine what he would say to us in light of that and what he has equally done to Ukraine. These guys are forming their own political and economic superpower (indeed competing ones) independent of Govts.

    • Sadly, Europe, including the UK, is placing greater emphasis on welfare and national debt than defence. The recent riots are mainly about the lack of funding for fundamental services such as education and the cost of living. There appear to be no protests about the lack of urgency on defence spending. That could all change if the US becomes a closer friend to Russia even after the midterm elections. I do believe Streeting is about to get more vocal about defence and hopefully stamp out the recent billions of cuts in military spending demanded by the Treasury. You could not write this stuff as fiction!

      • This is precisely the time to form a combined European armed forces on paper and comparing numbers. The European nation with the exception of in air nymbers the russians would be mince in a grinder now is the time when the benefits inter national exercises show their true worth multi national exercises are an everyday part of the European nations forces and the effectiveness of them is shown at times like this that the European forces already knows how to operate as a cohesive unit commonality of equipment is another plus. I’m not over worried about Russ. I’m more angry about the starting point we have to grow from.

  2. Giving Ukraine all we’ve now got, all Europe has now got, won’t stop Putin. Only the US can. Even us spending 5% of GDP, or 50%, in the next couple of years won’t improve that.

    I’m not being defeatist, but I don’t have the answer. Sure as hell Bennett doesn’t either.

    PS: Trump will be gone in two years time.

    • Of course Europe can.stop Russia but it will not.

      It is Europe’s purchase of Russian oil that has sustained the Russian war effort.

      If this country’s leaders really think we can hide behind Ukraine, then Poland and Germany, they have not been keeping up…

      Plus ca change…

      • I don’t think that is true unless you are including European manpower in that. At the moment it’s like a hundred men carrying buckets of water to a burning house and leaving them at the edge of the garden so that the one man who owns the property can chuck them on the fire. Full buckets are mounting up because he’s only one man.

        The Ukrainians are doing a wonderful job with the resources that they have but without manpower to mount large scale offensives and liberate swathes of their lands, they are confined to containing the Russians and whittling away at their forces and morale. The success of this strategy is almost entirely dependent on unknowable factors such as how long the Russian population is prepared to accept the burden of war with Ukraine.

        I would love to be proven wrong and if Ukraine attacks tomorrow and achieves something comparable to the 2022 Kharkiv counteroffensive, then I will happily eat my hat.

    • Europe out numbers Russia on every domain other than nuclear. It has many times the number of planes/tanks/ships/etc to Russia. If it wasn’t for the nuclear threat, Europe could very easily kick Russia out of Ukraine.

      The issue is Europe isn’t a single country and so it deciding to do something without a serious threat to individual countries is zero. Just have to go back to start of ww2 and how far Hitler managed to push things before countries actually did anything.

    • Europe is absolutely capable of out producing Russia on everything that it needs to win. Russia can’t even beat Ukraine. The only question is one of will, all backed up by enough money. The only thing that’ll ruin Europe is Europe. If we got real and spent what is needed we would’nt need the US anyway. I actually support the US if they want to go it alone. The defence of Europe is our own responsibilty.

    • Disagree. By every metric outside deploying weapons of mass destruction the European allies massively outgun and overmatch Russia. In naval terms, in airforce and in land forces. The facts speak for themselves.

    • I hope the issue of the power level of dragonfire is being sorted. Compared to similar systems are run at a far higher KW level I’m interested in how fast the units can be produced

    • James B, the US under Trump can’t and won’t stop Putin in his Ukraine war.
      I hope that the US would still honour Article 5 by committing more forces to Europe if an ENATO country is invaded, but that is not certain. We in ENATO have a fairly good chance of defeating (depleted) Russian forces in a European conventional war and perhaps the British and French nuclear deterrent stops Russia from going nuclear.

    • I don’t trust trump or America. Europe. To America is just a place to be plundered with it’s over hyped and overpriced products

  3. There is a difference between Russian attacks in Britain and attacks on Britain. Both incidents targeted Russian dissidents and might have been prevented by more effective border controls. Neither constituted a real casus belli.
    Doubling the defence budget wouldn’t deliver anything new for years. The best course is to speed up existing contracts to get ships and boats to sea and complete the reequipment of the army.

    • Indiscriminately harming British citizens (which the biological attack did) is an attack on Britain. Would you say that using a nuclear weapon to target a dissident is ok? Although you may kill other people, your actual target was a dissident, so surely that’s fine, right?

    • How would “border controls” help l, the novichok agents flew in on a commercial airliner for a holiday to admire one of our cathedrals, nothing illegitimate about their entry into the uk whatsoever.

  4. I’m all for spending 5% of GDP on defence immediately by cutting funding to places like the Civil Safety and Security Unit in the university’s School of Business at Leicester.

    The problem with these vacuum arguments is they never seem to state what we need to spend the money on straight away to deal with Russia. Again for the upteenth time we don’t have a boarder with Russia. The only solo conventional war the UK can fight with Russia is a naval and air war. Even our current diminished Air Force and navy can deal with the very diminished Russian navy and airforce today. So why do we need to double the budget overnight.

    It takes ten years to produce a new fighter jet or frigate. If you immediately doubled the budget what would you spend it on? It’s litterllaly not Britains job or NATO commitment to provide a large army to defend Eastern Europe. That’s literally the job of Poland, Germany and Finland that all have either large or rapidly growing army’s.

    People at the Treasury are not daft, they see right through nonsense straw man arguments like this instantly which is why they are reluctant to give the MoD massive overnight budget increases knowing full well it will spaff the cash up the wall.

    The Army keeps screaming at us that we are about to go to war yet they are reducing the active reserve force and reservist call ups are less than ten percent per annum of the forces event though we already have the smallest proportion of reservists of any major military on planet earth. If someone can tell me how we are about to go to war yet we are cutting reservist while spending £6 billion on a handful of armoured recce vehicles, £1.4 billion on jut 14 chinooks and £5 billion on a small number of APC’s I would love to know.

    The fact is a core budget of 3% of GDP is more than sufficient to deliver the security the UK needs and make a meaningful contribution to ENATO security in the high north and provide two rapidly deployable divisions.

    There is neither the need or will for the UK to rebuild the BAOR to fight an imaginary enemy and building a large standing army again in Europe probably reduces our security overall as it gives others the excuse to do nothing.

    The MoD doesn’t need more money it needs to stop wasting what it gets which is a vast sum of cash (£74 billion)

    • Russian warships carry a large number of very deadly, hard to stop missiles, along with air launched one, that could be launched in waves & volume to deplete our escorts SAM missiles. There only need to be a few getting through to destroy/disable our tiny escort fleet. We need to be designing our escorts with as many SAMs as we can pack in, not 12, 16, even 24. 30 may be too light a load out. Not only AShMs but also drones & decoys to be dealt with. We have very little to protect the nation from missile & drone strikes. Little civil defence either. Most even WW2 or cold war shelters/bunkers have been removed. Too heavy reliance on IT for everything with no back up analogue old-school systems in case IT is knocked out.

      • Frank I suggest you look at the actual Russian fleet as opposed to the fantasy Russian fleet.

        If your sinking our tiny escort fleet do you mean on land or at sea? At sea every escort we have is equipped with CAMM and Aster and easily able to deal with any Russian cruise missile. And how are they getting a targeting solution in the first place? They lack any form of air cover able to make it anywhere near the UK.

        In port then sky Sabre can defend all three of our naval bases and it’s probably the best system in the world for dealing with low flying cruise missiles. However it is impossible for any Russian surface ship to get near enough to us to launch cruise missiles without being rapidly sunk. Russia has no at sea replenishment capability as well so it can’t even out a fleet out into the Atlantic, they will literally run out of fuel.

        As for Russian warships being hard to kill, I suggest you ask the crew of the Moskva about that. The Russian lost a battle in the Black Sea against a country with no navy. They won’t last five minutes in the Baltic and North Atlantic. Their ports are also well within storm shadow range (Typhoon with Voyager) and TLAM range and we have proven in Ukraine that storm shadow can easily over come any Russian air defence and strike ships in port.

        With a navy of 19 top line escorts, two aircraft carriers armed with F35 and 7 Nuclear submarines the UK could take on any other navy in the North Atlantic excluding the USN and comfortably win.

        Yes I’m aware that we don’t currently have that many ships available but that’s the navy we have in build and pumping more money into defence won’t change those numbers and even just our diminished current state of 11 escorts, 6 SSN’s and 2 aircraft carriers is easily able to deal with any Russian potential fleet in the North Atlantic.

        • I didn’t say that Russian warships are hard to kill, don’t put words in my mouth. My point was that ours need to be able to survive prolonged saturation attacks. We only have 6 escorts with Camm & Aster, the rest, including the whole future T26 & T31 classes only have Camm. Russia could attack us not only with her fleet, but land based missiles, merchant/auxiliary ships carrying drones & missiles, plus aircraft launching them. Targetting could come from various means, submarines, aircraft, agents on merchant ships etc. I just believe we would be better off preparing for the worst rather than patting ourselves on the back with a fleet too small for peacetime & a build rate that hopes we fight no wars for another decade or more. All tech seems marvellous until it is proved or found wanting in battle.
          Never underestimate you enemy.

          • CAMM is the superior weapon for dealing with low flying saturation cruise missile attacks. The cold gas ejection and large magazine size of CAMM make it probably the best system in the world for this.

            Aster is fantastic too and much better at intercepting high altitude high energy targets. But our sea based air defence is absolutely top class across both T23 and T45 for sea skimming targets. It’s not great against ballistic anti ship missile yet but the Russians don’t have any.

            I’m all for preparing for the worst as well but we need to stop preparing to fight an imaginary enemy that just does not exist and we need to stop spreading the garbage that the UK is some how useless and undefended.

            The people perpetuating these myths are largely Kremlin backed and they do it to try and put influence on countries like the UK to produce political paralysis because they know if the UK stops opposing Russia then the rest of the west will crumble. They already took out America with Trump and they are close to knocking France out with Le Penn.

            The UK is the last thing holding it all together. We need an honest frank discussion about the threats our county does face and the deficiencies our military does have but they need to be held against the actual threat that our enemies pose which is actually quite far away pretty limited at present in the case of Russia and Iran and very very far away in the case of China or North Korea.

            Once we have all 19 escorts we have on order and or build and once we have 7 Astute’s all in service with the temporary maintenance backlog dealt with the UK will have a immensely capable navy able to dominate the North Atlantic and a far more capable force than anything Russia is ever likely to be able to field in the region again.

            Russia hasn’t built a surface combatant bigger than a small frigate for 40 years. It has less new SSN’s than we do and it has to spread them over two oceans not one like us.

            Our surface combatants have proven themselves at sea against missile saturation attacks, Russias top air defence asset at sea could not stop two old sub sonic anti ship missiles. The rest of its navy has been taken out by jet skis carrying explosives.

            This is the reality of the threat and what we have to face it.

            UK defence spending does not take place in a vaccum, part of the reason the navy has been run down is because its principal adversary had no navy to speak of. Once the Russias started spending we started matching back in 2021.

            • The thing that gets me is the criticism that the UK hasn’t committed enough to NATO ground forces in Eastern Europe but when the discussion turns to the defence of the UK, suddenly we’re entirely dependent on our own forces for our own defence and Russia is going to launch its full salvo at us alone, for which we need to be prepared for. Either we are working as an alliance or we’re not. If we are going to be sole operators then no amount of brigades and Challengers in Estonia is going to protect us, in which case we should be focusing resources on the direct defence of the UK and its surrounding waters because that’s where our houses are and where our children live and, after all, what we’re paying the Government to protect.

              We can spend any reasonable amount of money but we’re not simultaneously going to have an army and air force as big as, say, Germany while also having a larger navy to protect the High North AND operate a Nuclear deterrent. Where are our concessions on NATO commitments for being one of only two E.NATO Nuclear deterrents, which is almost a separate military branch in itself? Does the UK tax payer just have to spend more to have this over and above everything else, just because.

              • Couldn’t agree more about the nonsense double standards. We are either engaged in a ground war with Russia in which European states army’s and or the rest of NATO will be involved or we are in a solo war with Russia where the army will play little if any part.

              • It’s a Freudian slip. Everyone knows that we are more loyal to our allies than they are to us.
                If Russia played a smart game and tried to isolate the UK from its allies, it’s not implausible to assume that allies would resort to self-preservation tactics and leave us to fend for ourselves.

                • Yeah but if that happens, we are an island thousands of miles away from Russia with the most powerful navy and airforce in the region and the ability to easily blockade Russian shipping.

                  In many ways it might be better for Britain and the world for us to fight Russia without Allie’s. We can do them lots of economic harm from a distance, with little cost and they can’t do much to us with no land boarder to put their army on.

                  If your fighting a solo war against Britain you can’t go around cutting American internet cables or firing missiles over Scandinavia and Eastern Europe.

                  Every strike package must come around the top of the Scandinavia, through the bear gap and the GIUK gap to get anywhere near us.

                  Meanwhile Russia tankers and cargo ships are easily grabbed by us in the channel, North Sea and Mediterranean all from Sovereign UK bases and all with cargos we can legally grab in a time of war and resell.

    • Well, to start, 10 infantry battalions stock full of ATGM and driving around in Patrias. Artillery with lots of GBAD and AD for our airfields. Infantry because the Ukraine has shown what they can still do, and we need to be able to take casualties, GBAD for obvious reasons, drone and aircraft defense and if we don’t defend our airfields all those shiny expensive planes will be in gone in the first 2 days. That can be done relatively quickly IMO. All the other big shiny objects will have to done over time with a priority on 155 artillery and attack submarines.

      • I agree, sounds like exactly the kind of force we should be adding to the army. But you don’t need £80 billion a year for that. You can get 10 battalions for more like £800 million a year and if they were reservists it’s more like £80 million a year.

        It’s almost impossible to add £80 billion a year to the MoD in peace time without wasting most of it, the only way to spend that type of money rapidly would be to give it to Ukraine and they would spend it on US, South Korean and other countries weapons.

        Even if we closed our ABM missile gap which I think is our most glaring gap you can buy an AEGIS ashore system and 8 SAMPT/NG batteries for about £10 billion. That’s about 6 weeks of the higher spending these “experts” advocate and you would not see a single system for five years.

        All the countries that have give it 5% of GDP have pretty small economies, had almost no armed forces to begin with and have a military draft.

      • And if I can add, get a replacement order in for the B1 Rivers asap especially if they’re going in the next 2 years. Presence in UK waters and can be seen and can support a helo/uav/drones. Kind of flys the flag too. Three-four of them. Some here have advocated for up to six. Should be “cheap as ships” and complement the T31s and keep the B2s out and about doing their thing.

    • I don’t trust trump or America. Europe. To America is just a place to be plundered with it’s over hyped and overpriced products

    • Jim, I have seen nothing about reducing the number of reservists. The only thing that I have seen is that several reservist exercises have been cancelled, as have most regular army collective training exercises been cancelled.

  5. NATO excluding USA has a gdp that is 11 x that of Russia. Even the JEF nations have a combined GDP thar is 3 x that of Russia. Getting MOD to spend well, cut waste, lean processes and managment is required to meet need and balance the tressury books.

    Russia today is spending 6% of GDP on defence after 4 years of open conflict. JEF spending 3% well is suffient to deter.

    • It’s now the size that counts but how you spend it. Finland for example has a 10th of the population and a 15th of the GDP yet somehow they have more tanks, IFV’s artillery and AD then we have.

    • We could throw 5percent of gdp into defence and it wouldn’t change anything for years. We don’t have shipbuilding, we don’t design or build aircraft BECAUSE WE’VE NOWHERE TO DO IT. People in the media and as usual, the government of the day think that the more money is thrown at a problem everything will be fine

      • Andy, of course we have shipbuilding – just about every RN ship and submarine is built in Britain. We build aircraft including military aircraft such as Typhoon, or at least parts of it. We can’t build army vehicles from scratch or general-issue small arms and until recently we couldn’t make gun barrels.

  6. Even war against Trump’s America wouldn’t surprise me the way he’s going. He’s like a rabid dog attacking everyone one way or another & can’t seem to help Putin enough.
    But to imply we’re even close to having enough to fight a war as we stand today after decades of cuts far below what we need even for peacetime is insanity bordering on treasonous.

    • He would never get it past congress. It’s one thing to do a little bombing of Iran with little risk to us service man, and then try and cover up the few losses, it’s a whole different matter going against an opponent that would send back American body bags in their thousands. His unstable but his powers aren’t unlimited

  7. Wars are usually won by the side that has the larger.armed forces, the better training and weapons, the larger manufacturing base.and, above all, the greater wealth. It is fair enough that Dr. Bennett concentrates on the UK’s many military and civil lacunae, there is much to be sorted.

    But in the bigger picture, leaving the USA on one side for now, ENATO has:
    – More than three times Russia’s population (520m v 146m)/manpower
    – Much better-trained and better-equipped forces than Russia’s conscripts
    – A very large manufacturing sector, particularly military equipment
    – Many times Russia’s wealth.

    Russia is actually a paper tiger in many respects. What clouds the picture for many is that they have the world’s largest nuclear arsenal. But that is also a paper tiger, because the UK and France have enough nuclear missiles to raze every Russian military base and formation, and then some. It is a Mexican standoff, unless Putin believes that the West would not retaliate to a limited strike on European territory.

    Russia’s overall military and economic weakness is what has pushed them to devise a different form of warfare, where attack is by clandestine grey zone methods, missiles and drones, and defence is primarily anti-air, as ENATO would quickly achieve air supremacy and eventually air dominance. The biggest threat they pose is stirring up Russian-speaking minorities in Estonia and Latvia, or creating a political situation where they occupy Svalbard or conspire to bring the government down in Moldova. Basically, pin-pricks to see if ENATO is prepared to stand up for itself.

    We need to leave them in no doubt about firm military action by NATO or ENATO. Every Russian aircraft or drone entering European air space needs to be shot down without mercy, as is starting to happen. Any clandestine build-up of Russian forces intending to foment trouble in Eastern Europe needs to be met by larger NATO formations, fully equipped with long range and air defence missiles and numerous FPV drones and LLAD/C-UAV systems.

    The big-picture problems to be overcome here are:

    1. Command through NATO. We like to think of it as a jolly party of 32 musketeers, but the reality when the chips are down is one superpower and 31 medium, small and very small states. Over-dependence on US leadership, involvement and reinforcements looks increasingly to be a risky gamble, dependent on what POTUS decides to think each day.

    We have to crack on with this European Security Council proposed by the EU, which would put in place a leadership body, which would need to expand to having a military committee and a Chiefs of Staff organisation. Basically, turning NATO into two allied organisations, one for North America, one for Europe. (It is how the UK and USA operated in WW2).

    2. The liberal, restrained West shrinks from taking any belligerent action in the face of aggression, hoping it will go away. We need some leaders who are prepared to take action where needed, from wholesale seizure of shadow tankers and confiscation of their cargo, to shooting down Russian aircraft entering NATO airspace, to deploying large troop concentrations on Ukraine’s Western borders – and threatening to use them if Ukraine is being overrun.

    That is all before looking at the UK’s weaknesses in home defence and military capability.

    • Hi Cripes, we mess with freedom of navigation in peace time at our peril. Russian ships in international waters should not be ceased if they are only subject to UK or EU sanctions. Only the UN can introduce such sanctions.

      Ensuring freedom of navigation is far more important for the world than any war in Ukraine.

      We can see what impact it’s having now on the world just in Hormuz and the Red Sea.

      We talk about shadow fleet tankers like they are all the same but they are not, we have only rightly targetted tankers flying fake flags which we can do so under international law and often with the flag countries permission.

    • Cripes, don’t forget that the EU has conducted several military operations over many years with existing mechanisms.

  8. War prep means building mass – and whilst it takes 4 years to train a fast jet pilot and about the same amount to build the platform we need to start now. People on this forum were arguing this point 4 years ago when we should have been growing our mass. It’s not too soon to start and so I’d like to see another 100 FGR4s ordered with a commensurate wide in for the FJ pilot training and intake.

    • Wondering if it would be quicker and even cheaper to refurbish any spare T1, 2, 3 Typhoons that might be being disposed of, up to T4 standard? Isn’t Turkey looking at buying 20 odd from Qatar/Oman? The UK could top up its stocks with a similar quantity.

      • At an absolutely ridiculous 70 million a pop for the new radar, it would add considerably more capability to simply replace the entire Typhoon fleet with F35A, adding far more bang for your buck and significantly increasing European NATO capacity….

        A proposition of which could be replaced in turn with GCAP as it becomes available.

        I would view it in a similar way to the rearmament of the 1950’s, when the RAF took Canadian made Sabers and US surplus B29’s while we waited for the V Bombers and the Hunter.

  9. ‘The country has suffered two Kremlin-initiated chemical warfare attacks, in London in 2006 (Polonium) and in Salisbury in 2018 (Novichok).’

    Both attacks used enough CBRN material to kill thousands.

    ‘we know Russia is conducting a campaign of hybrid attacks and sabotage across Europe.’ Louise Sandher-Jones

    Beyond time to get real about the threat. An increase to 5% of gdp would be about £50bn/year extra defence spending.

    For the next 3 years (as indicated necessary by the Defence Secretary), on the back of a fag packet, that looks like:

    Air defence: Timely, resilient, and integrated command and control (C2) including: GUARDIAN, the Air Battle Management system fully integrated into the NATO IAMD C2 network; and NEXUS, a cloud-based C2 decision-making solution employing Artificial Intelligence. £10bn p.a.

    ‘NATO First’—stepping up on European security by leading in NATO, with strengthened nuclear, new tech, and updated conventional capabilities. Formed two division army corps. Restore combined arms training in Suffield. £10bn p.a.

    Move to warfighting readiness—establishing a more lethal ‘integrated force’ equipped for the future, and strengthened homeland defence. The T.A. haven’t got any kit. Implement 2023 Haythornthwaite Review in full. £10bn p.a.

    Engine for growth—driving jobs and prosperity through a new partnership with industry, radical procurement reforms, and backing UK businesses. Radical root-and-branch reform of defence procurement—combined with substantial investment in innovation, novel technology, advanced manufacturing, and skills
    UK innovation driven by lessons from Ukraine—harnessing drones, data, and digital warfare to make our Armed Forces stronger and safer. R&D and flexible future proof production facilities for mass production of drone types proven to be effective in Ukraine. Develop and train drone tactics Suffield £10bn p.a.

    Whole-of-society approach—widening participation in national resilience and renewing the Nation’s contract with those who serve. ‘The MOD should explore, with wider Government, options for a ‘new deal’ for the defence of Critical National Infrastructure (CNI), rooted in partnership between Defence and private-sector and allied operators of infrastructure that is most critical to the continuity of essential services in the UK. Models used by Nordic and Baltic states provide useful examples of how to incentivise, support, and work with operators to mutual benefit. To support this new deal, the Royal Navy should take a new leading and coordinating role in securing undersea pipelines, cables, and maritime traffic carrying the information, energy, and goods upon which national life depends’ (SDR 2025) £10bn p.a.

    ‘People sleep peaceably in their beds at night because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf.’

    • ‘The Netherlands will buy more CV90 infantry fighting vehicles, additional bridge-laying tanks, a replacement for its unreliable Kodiak combat engineer vehicle, and new tracked support and heavy recovery vehicles from Germany’s FFG’ 26 Oct 2026

      What is wrong with Britain?

  10. Trump is favourable to Putin, America is acting for its own interests only and are we not seeing decline of American power. Russia is weak outright conventional fight but will act sub threshold to undermine Europe, quite easy with deniable attacks.

  11. The Russians will use a hybrid war, they have not the capacity to fight a full frontal attack against European Nato. Getting to 5% of GDP on defence would be politically very difficult without a really big event happening in the world stage which changed the political backdrop in the UK and Europe.
    The big questions the UK Government need help on which he should have concentrated on how does the UK unwind itself from close co-operation on intelligence, large programmes like the F35 and Dreadnought etc with a partner few in the UK trust any more without having a major effect on UK defence capability.

  12. Calm down dear! The Midterms are nearly here. Things may change after them. Hybrid war leans to sabotage, so the UK may need to face a taboo. There are not enough armed police to cover every defence related factory or storage warehouse. We may need to copy India & allow small .22/.32 handguns for ex military/ex police, private security guards.

      • Oh he will throw his toys out of the pram, but you can bet that returning officers are very careful to show that the vote was done properly.

        • Assuming the Orange Oaf has the attention span to sit through a film, make him watch ‘ Civil War’ and see if the message stinks in..

          You might have to mention to him that would be him on the Oval office floor at the end, as I doubt the suggestion would sink in…..

  13. Look at recent siuations concerning thr RN. There are times when we don’t have any frigates, or destroyers, or attack subs, available. The infrastructure needed is struggling and needs to be sorted? 3.5%? 5%? Whatever – getting the infrastructure sorted has to be done and we are fast running out of time. It needs to stop being about percentages and start being about capabilities. That means mending what needs to be mended first, then put things in place to cover areas where we currently depend on the US.

  14. It’s always logically sound to ensure that you have a proper contingency plan to fight and win a war without allied support. It is also logically sound to foster allied support wherever possible for obvious reasons- particularly when facing the (thankfully long gone) strategic weight of the Soviet Union. So you need a force structure with the mass and broad-spectrum combat capability to operate independently while also focusing on ensuring that your systems are interoperable with allied coalitions. The MOD was relatively good at striking this balance until the post-2008 cuts.

  15. I don’t think any recent Prime Ministers (post Boris, anyway) have been in denial about Trump. They simply don’t make things worse by saying what they know. But they all know. What’s happening secretly will be revealed in 30 years time – doubtless long after I’m dead… unless I become a centenarian!

    Telling the truth about Russian aggression is now down to the media, as the evidence with supporting information is available. The government is talking about stocking up… just stop and think what that means… it was only a few years ago we were being told NOT to stock pile during Covid.

    Too many commentators on UKDJ are fighting “20teens” battles – and losing, and getting sore. We need to be fighting 2030 battles now to have a chance. Someone said on another post we should have 100,000 new rifles… who for? A million drones, maybe!

    One grouse is the turning off the Long Wave transmitter at Droitwich earlier this year, and no longer having TACAN or its like.Jaguars had inertial navigation – which should by now be so improved that it’s as good as GPS.

    Oh, and we all need to invest in a wireless (note the name) that works by winding a handle! I hope the Long Wave facility has just been mothballed and not dismantled. The twin masts are still there, as they are used for other things, well I think they are!

  16. The mid-terms might rain Trump in a little, but the damage Trump has done to America and Nato will take several decades to put right. We still have however 2 more years of Trump sucking up to Putin (for what ever reason) so affectively Nato will be standing without America.
    Is Trump a traitor, probably yes, but we in the UK and in Europe have quite a number of traitors in high up positions within the SC and our political elite who have reduced our military and ability to respond to an attack to it current state.

  17. Lots of interesting arguments and perspectives, and the point about not needing to fight a land war is fair. We might be able to have a skirmish or two on the beaches but after the first couple of weeks inland.. we are left with nothing. We do not have any effective air defence, especially on the scale being absorbed by Ukraine. A couple of point defence T45 destroyers is woefully inadequate. If we are an unsinkable aircraft carrier we need to able to defend it so it can be used for aircraft and a staging point. We may not sink but we can still be devastated. Our infrastructure is fragile, increasingly dependent on complex digital communications, health services already running near capacity and we aren’t in a hot war! Food production as in WW1 and WW2 is inadequate. We’ve recently shutdown one of our major oil refineries and also closing steel production. All in the name of ‘just-in-time’ tax cutting austerity. And we have our very own fascist ultra right wing mobs to contend with, underwhelming numbers of police, and an unbelievable backlog in the courts with prisons stuffed to overflowing. Talk about depressing!

    • You would think that getting existing prison cells refurbished so they can be returned to service, would be a priority, but it seems sadly not. Yes there are hard right, but do not forget the hard left forming a weird alliance with the jihadists.

          • Go and read it yourself. What has the left got to do with jihadists? And in any case how do you identify a single characteristic applying to them all? It could be argued if you cared to analyse that actually so-called jihadists are actually hard right and potentially fascist! And what is ‘left’?

    • Nickc, you say that we do not need to fight a land war, presumably meaning that the UK is unlikely to be invaded. I agree with that but of course we have planned to fight a land war in Europe since 1949. We currently commit to providing two divsions, a Corps HQ and support units to the ARRC, one of SACEUR’s two strategic reserve army formations. We have used our army to fight in wars and deploy on peace support operations in many places over the years.

      • If you read the comments, I was referring to the need to fight a land war on or soil. And yes, we have planned to fight a land war, and yes I do know as I was one of those, but the point is that would be largely in someone else’s country. Forward defence yes, and hopefully forward pushing an enemy out of that country.

  18. In the end the UK needs to get it into its head that it’s very likely NATO is finished.

    The US is off on its own and may even end up an unfriendly Neutral in regards to the EU and other independent European nations. The EU may end up simply navel gazing or hedgehog up or it may fragment or even become its very own Geopolitical superpower..

    But within this there is now a chance ( a small but real one) the the UK ends up at war with Russia and only having 1 or 2 allies and a lot of warm hugs.. very much like Ukraine.

    So the UK seriously needs to be planning for how it fights its own war… not as a supporter in an alliance.. but how will it fight Russia to terms that were not utterly devastating… let’s be clear the UK could not win a war against Russia, but it does not need to, it simply needs to not lose… AKA a force a balanced armistice and peace.

    Lucky for the UK its greatest weapon of war that it’s used for 1000 years is still in place.. it’s geostrategic positioning as an island that straddles the main sea routes of Northern Europe and has easy access to the Atlantic and beyond.

    Therefore its entire focus needs to be on that fact..

    1) a navy that can exercise sea control of the northern seas.
    2) an airforce that supports the sea control
    3) UK air defence, airforce, navy and land based
    4) the ability to strike Russia with conventional strategic weapons over and over
    5) civil contingencies..so the nation keeps running
    6) an army that can be deployed to support any ally that wants to fight Russia on the mainland ( but this requires allies that are willing to fight Russia on the ground).
    7) effective nuclear deterrence
    8) effective defensive and offensive cyber
    9) security forces to protect against grey warfare
    10) political warfare to stop Russia attacking the national will via political warfare.

    10 points to fighting a war with Russia on our own or with only a handful of allies ( say Norway and Canada)

    • NATO is good in fact. The only blot is the USA going full traitor under the fascist imbecility of Trump. The rest of NATO is united & has even grown with Sweden & Finland joining as a result of Putin’s aggression & wild threats. Russia is weaker than ever having wasted do much blood & treasure failing to defeat Ukraine & refusing to cut its losses.

      • The simple fact is article five requires unanimous consensus from all NATO member states to be invoked… as it stands one nation could prevent NATO supporting the UK via article 5 and there is no actual requirement of article 5 even when invoking..

        NATO only works if all Nations show total commitment.. and that’s just not being shown.

    • I agree and I think to a certain extent we are seeing planning for that. The UK main issue is it lacks or has lacked an ability to door much harm to Russia beyond a blockade. That’s why we have seen so much emphasis on deep strike cruise missiles with enough range to launch from the UK and the UK seems to be principally relying on the ability to keep Russian air and naval forces to the east of the bear gap to prevent Russia from doing any harm to the UK.

      In true British way of war fashion it’s also making major efforts to keep a land based threat form a foreign Allie on the main front viable (Ukraine).

      Distant blockade in the North Atlantic and Mediterranean, with deep strike launched from the UK and the maintenance of a land based front to chew the enemies men and materials up is the extract way we won world war 2 up until June 1944 and it would be the main strategy we would use against Russia in a non NATO wide war.

      The UK is not in a bad place to wage such a war today relative to Russia and will likely be in a much better place to do so by the early 2030’s especially if we can sort something out on ABM capability.

    • Well said Jonathan, that required 3.5% to back the 2024 SDSR, with a force structure updated and suitably enlarged for the task.

      Despite all Labours protestations in opposition regarding the perilous state of the Armed forces and need for rearmament, they have done the square root of absolutely fu#k all.

    • NATO is composed of a large number of countries, of whom the US is just one. Albeit a large and capable member. The current(?) strategy is to wait for US reinforcement, but that is rapidly being reviewed. NATO can easily exist without the US, we just have to get there. And ultimately it is not in US interests to come out of NATO anyway. Their eastern and northeastern seaboard is defended by NATO. If they were not members then that would fall entirely to them, and if Russia were to conquer Europe the US would be faced with Russia to the north and east, and china to the west!

      • The problem is to invoking Article 5 requires unanimous consensus from all NATO member states.. that means every single nation must agree to it.. even then every nation then decides how it will support.. that could involve a stiff letter.

        NATO was always about will over the structure of the alliance treaty ( which is actually a very weak treaty).

        • And that means we need to be more capable of going it alone! Or at least credibly capable of defending ourselves along with partners, instead of relying on them to do the defence for us! Peace Dividend and Austerity lulled the previous round of Governments into a false sense of security, and perhaps that is why the report into Russian influence was not really followed up on.

  19. seems that thee of our Vanguard SSBN’s are at sea at the same time. seems like the RN is turning a corner, its doubled down on SSBN availability, hopefully SSN now follow suit. No idea what kind of armament each Vanguard is carrying but even if only two are armed that’s quite the deterrent to Russia.

  20. Amazing points made by all and sundry. Without America, the future would look indeed bleak but there is still plenty of room for hope. Something is afoot in Europe. Populist Hungary has fallen and so has Serbia. Russia next? These events, like the Berlin Wall can happen overnight. Hundreds of thousands of young Russian men are being ‘meatgrinded’ – hundreds of thousands of potential Russian families are not to be – thousands of Russian women
    without partners – Russian parents without their sons after all that effort in bringing them up The situation is catastrophic.. Autocratic populism means that a leader can just point at anyone and they are ‘dissappeared”, without proof, without any recourse to justice! Is this really what the World wants?

    • Meat grinder mentality is awful, the reports of travelling crematoriums behind Russian lines. Think Russia accepts this, life is cheap.

      • I’m afraid it’s hard baked into Russian mentality. The man in charge (Czar, Soviet Politburo, or the modern hybrid of both systems under Putin) have one thing in common, the Russian people are a resource to be used as they see fit.

        If Mass slaughter is needed, so be it, they are only peasants…

    • Some young Russian women are getting rich by marrying some poor contract soldier sent to the front, then collecting his death payout, & then moving onto the next poor soldier.
      As for America, not all think like Trump. Even MAGA is split over Trump’s love of Putin. As Churchill said ” You can trust America to do the right thing, after they have tried everything else”.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here