The Defence Secretary has called the Scottish National Party’s support for unilateral nuclear disarmament a white flag policy and said the party must explain how it would square that with membership of a nuclear alliance, according to remarks made to reporters in Glasgow.
Wes Streeting was asked about the First Minister’s repeated claim that the government in Westminster is leaving Scotland short of defence.
He said: “We’ve got HMS Prince of Wales currently out on a major exercise now, so I think it’s very visible proof that what the First Minister said is both irresponsible and unfounded. I don’t think the SNP should be playing party politics with national defence and security. We’d much rather work with us.
“In terms of the risk of leaving the UK with insufficient defence, one of the biggest risks facing that security is the SNP’s position on unilateral nuclear disarmament. It is by far and away the most important deterrent that we have, and it’s not just the UK’s deterrent, it’s NATO’s deterrent. So any time the SNP says that a separate Scotland can be a NATO member, they have to first explain how their white flag policy on unilateral nuclear disarmament would work under a nuclear alliance.”
The question has followed the party since 2012, when its conference voted by a narrow margin to drop opposition to NATO membership while keeping opposition to nuclear weapons, a position that would require an independent Scotland to join an alliance whose strategic concept rests on nuclear deterrence while removing the British deterrent from Faslane and Coulport.
Every member of NATO except France takes part in the alliance’s Nuclear Planning Group, and the three countries that joined most recently signed up to a strategic concept describing nuclear weapons as the supreme guarantee of allied security. New members are admitted by unanimous agreement of the existing ones.












The Nats are terrible on defence. When there is a perceived lack of something, they are quick to complain that Scotland is being neglected but when there is a hint of positivity they seek to undermine and pooh-pooh it as it challenges their divisive agenda. Only today I was reading an article by the Herald Newspaper on Facebook about Babcock Rosyth and the Type 31 program and there they were in the comment section, the Cyber Nats, moaning that the Herald spends too much time taking about Babcock and that they are a mouthpiece of Westminister. They can’t just be happy for the workers of Rosyth and the opportunities that have been made available. Always with the weaselly, mealy-mouthed discourse.
There is a reason for the weaselly mealy-mouthed discourse. Your first sentence is an opinion statement, fair enough you have the right to do so. But, the rest of your rant had nothing to do with any justification for your opinion. Quite probably because you don’t have a valid argument to support that opinion. In fact there is a far more positive and constructive view from the ‘Nats’ if you cared to look. Being against nuclear weapons, based a short drive from Glasgow, does not mean there is no opinion on defence. Defence is far more than Trident.
Yes but it is the gold standard “big stick” that stoops others from bullying with you, maybe not fiddling with, but defo not bullying.
Yes, gold standard big stick. BUT, at what point does it get to be used? After two weeks of fighting? And that is it.
We’ve relied on this while scaling back conventional stuff. Watch Wargame. Essentially we have an all or nothing defence capability that has to be resorted to far too soon in any conflict. Oh Mr Putin please stop your novichock, and drones, ballistics, internet interference, otherwise we will have to nuke you!
It’ll hopefully never be used. But it does it’s job well. You don’t see Trump bombing North Korea, the Russians are using their nukes as a bargaining chip holding off full intervention by the west and while certainly at risk of proxies and attack the Isrealies don’t have to worry about invasion . It’s not a perfect system to stop all attacks but it certainly dissuades an invasion scenario
That is exactly what it was meant to do, so in that respect it works. But it is our capacity to endure a sustained attack especially asymmetrically that is the real issue. The more we rely on nuclear as the backstop and reduce our conventional capacity it means that we hit the last resort decision time much much quicker. The threshold of subversive and low level attacks get higher and higher and our ability to send a ‘message’ conventionally reduces further. Our current policy is in effect mutual suicide or submission.
But, they DO bully us! At which point does the victim fight back, and with what? While not wanting nuclear weapons especially in our backyard, upping our conventional capabilities means pushing the nuclear retaliation threshold higher up the spectrum of available responses. Salisbury, social media bots, political interference, undersea cables and pipelines, global political influence, . . . . .
Yet as in the article they are quite prepared to go for NATO membership under the nuclear umbrella,now surely not having the weapons a a country is their choice but it’s hypocritical to shout against them and then agree to be defended by them!
Hi Nickc,
As you frequently support the SNP defence position, please be good enough to confirm what the SNP Defence plan IS for an independent Scotland rather than criticising others for questioning their position.
While they debate how to fund and raise a Defence Force, the SNP seem to have a “cross you fingers” position that the remaining UK will continue to protect Scotland for 10 years post any independence vote.
While I can summarise it in a few sentences, there are actually significant papers already in the public domain explaining the position. An independent Scotland would contribute to NATO as much as it does already, and we would focus on the Nordic and GIA gap as we do now. That would actually allow rUK to concentrate on the continental front. Not having nuclear weapons in Scotland also means that rUK can concentrate its ballistic and missile defences (such as they are, watch Wargame!) elsewhere.
“An independent Scotland would contribute to NATO as much as it does already, and we would focus on the Nordic and GIA gap as we do now.”
As a Nation Scotland has no Defence Force is my point.
As previously discussed on this site, Scotland (SNP) does not want to deminish the UK armed forces by taking the 8% share attributed to an independent Scotland.
Therefore, what will Scotland contribute to eNATO if it currently has no Defence Force generation planning in place?
You are guilty of making some peculiar status quo projections to a hypothetical future situation. Scotland has no more defence forces then England does. We both share a proportion of the existing facilities. FYI we share that responsibility and it would be resolved during independence negotiations if that scenario arises. Perhaps you need to see the illogical links posed across your sentences! Where on ‘this site’ has Scotland stated that it would not assume responsibility for its 9% share that we have already contributed to? Scotland would assume responsibility for the elements it inherits. On independence the status quo would cease to exist so you cannot project that forward.
I don’t do SKY TV and Nicola is not a trusted voice for many Scots.
Scotland has a proud and illustrious Military history that no rational commentator could criticise and I for one will never go there
However, asking for a Scottish National Party statement of substance, detailing the defence plans for the protection of her citizens seems to be treasonous to some.
“Downie says SNP has no serious plan for Scotland’s security
By George Allison – October 23, 2026”
“The SNP is not serious about independence or defence and is taking its supporters for fools, Labour MP Graeme Downie has said, responding to an interview in which the party’s Westminster leader confirmed he has written and costed a plan for an independent Scottish army, navy and air force but is holding it back until the next independence referendum debate.”
“They say they want to be in NATO and enjoy protection from a nuclear umbrella but not have it based in Scotland. They say they want to support defence jobs but have taken no action to build the skills the defence industry needs. They say they support our armed forces but stop Cadet units from building valuable community links by banning activity inside state schools.
“This is the same story from the SNP. Secrecy, fantasy and no serious plan for Scotland’s security.”
Dave Doogan, the SNP’s Westminster leader and the member for Angus and Perthshire Glens, told this publication that he drafted and costed the plan about two and a half years ago, that it now needs a refresh, and that he would publish it once enough people were asking the question. “Why not release the defence plan now? Well, a good reason is that it needs a refresh, but it’s designed to answer a question when enough people are asking that question, and that will come when we’re having the next independence referendum debate,” he said.
I’m asking the question.
What is the SNP defence plan for an independent Scotland?
If you refuse to watch something that explains the position then nobody can convince you. Who said ANYTHING about Nicola Sturgeon? YOUR opinion is yours. If you prevent yourself from learning you will never learn. If plans are not yet developed then they can’t be released. You interpret everything merely where it supports you ideas. You will never know if you don’t look at everything involved. George Allison is not in the SNP so he is in no position to state what they will or will not do, which in any case will vary depending on prevailing future circumstances. Which is EXACTLY what a strategic planner should do. Graham Downie is also not privy to SNP plans. So what they say is pure speculation. And to repeat the large number of words that will answer your questions are already in the public domain. Go and look. Demanding someone else repeats what is already written is not a realistic question. I am not going to cut and paste several hundred pages of text just for you. Look them up yourself, but you’ve already made your mind up regardless. Your lack of understanding of strategic planning is evident by your demand that someone else’s detailed plans must be published for the world to see. Is that how they planned for D Day? Go and read what has already been published and is in the public domain.
The problem with the people questioning the SNP is that they do not read any of the actual published reports and white papers. The defence for an independent Scotland is no different to the defence of the current UK! Which is predicated as it has done increasingly since the 90s on membership of NATO. UK relies on other nations already. While it is a docudrama Wargame illustrates the problem UK faces. Does Scotland not already contribute to defence, and arguably proportionately more on a manpower basis?
Trident is the UK’s insurance policy, it is nothing else. Its whole purpose is to prevent another world war. Without it we are open to anyone who “fancies a go”. NATs are by their policies determined to destroy the UK as a nation and like PC and SF are living in a fantasy world. Even should their dream came true, how on earth are they going to defend the high north and with what? The RN has 5 old and very tired frigates, 4 x SSBN of which one is always on patrol, 2 x Carriers ( 1 always available), 6 x Destroyers of which 2 are available. Other vessels are either MCMV’s or patrol vessels and can’t really bring much to bare. The RFA who has to resupply them has effectively 9 vessels 4 of which can resupply the FF/DD and carriers, the rest are amphibious vessels or an undersea survey vessel. In short an independent Scotland will be a win for the Russians and any other potential foe opposed to NATO or the UK.
👍
sSNP defence strategy? They don’t have one or the knowledge to make one
Wrong. There is ample public domain documentation on the subject, from the SNP too. There is a defence policy, which was contained in the Scotland’s Future tome of 2014 and aside from others also the white papers published over the last few years. And, there are numerous high ranking veterans in the SNP. Please do some research before exposing your opinion to the world. And also not forgetting that we already contribute our population share to defence as do all the other similar sized nations within NATO and Europe.
Nick, you keep saying there’s ample public domain documentation but I can’t find it. What little is there is contradictory.
Please explain the current position of the SNP on defence.
Also Scotland would need to spend 5% of gdp to get into NATO. Where’s that money coming from?
Also do you not think it’s hypocrisy for the SNP to rely on the ultimate protection of a nuclear deterrent and the decrying nukes in Scotland?
👍