Deliveries of new Aster Block 1 missiles will begin later this year, and considerable progress has been made over the past twelve months in upgrading the existing stock to the same standard, though the number converted so far is being withheld on security grounds, according to an answer given in Parliament.
Ben Obese-Jecty, the Conservative member for Huntingdon, asked what progress has been made on upgrading all Royal Navy Aster missiles to Block 1 standard through Sea Viper Evolution Capability 1.
Luke Pollard, Minister of State for Defence, said: “The upgrading of missiles to Aster Block 1 standard is being undertaken through the Aster Mid-Life Refresh programme. The exact number of missiles upgraded to date cannot be disclosed owing to security concerns, however considerable progress has been made over the last 12 months. Additional deliveries of new Aster Block 1 missiles will commence later this year.”
Aster is the missile family behind Sea Viper, the air defence system carried by the six Type 45 destroyers, and the Block 1 standard brings an improved capability against ballistic missiles as well as aircraft and cruise missiles. Sea Viper Evolution is the wider upgrade programme announced after HMS Diamond and HMS Richmond spent months intercepting Houthi drones and missiles in the Red Sea, where the Royal Navy fired Aster in anger for the first time.
Stock depth has been the question hanging over that capability since those engagements, because a destroyer carries forty-eight cells and an intercept uses one missile or two. Replacing what was expended and raising the standard of what remains are the two halves of the same problem, and the department has consistently declined to put numbers on either.
Aster is produced by MBDA, with final assembly in France and significant British content including the Sampson radar and the command and control system from BAE Systems. The Defence Investment Plan commits £6 billion to munitions this Parliament, including £1.5 billion for an always on production pipeline.












“security grounds” again. Amazing how many times this excuse has been used over the last few years.
Excuse for what? I would not expect to be told these numbers.
Agree.. Some things have to remain confidential.
I agree also. Any information in the public domain can be seen by an aggressor. Some things much remain secret. That’s why we have the Official Secrets Act.
You can guarantee it won’t be the entire inventory Geoff.
Sea Ceptor is fine, as the retiring T23s add 32 missiles to the stocks and T45 only takes 24. The first 2 T31 will apparently only have an almost useless 12, bloody good job the gun system is so robust!!!
12 is fine for self-defence given they can quadpack CAMM. For a low-cost GP assets that’s perfectly acceptable imo.
You can only quad pack CAMM when the Mk 41 cells are installed and there’s been conflicting information when that will happen. Best case is the last three ships are built with the cells installed with the first two retrofitted at a later date.
Quad packing CAMM into a strike length mk41 seems to be a waste of its space unless they can come up with a magical double stacked CAMM. Be good for dual pack CAMM-MR if that ever happens. There’s the ExLS for CAMM, why don’t they use that or an evolved CAMM farm with a more compacted arrangement?
One Army Sky Sabre 32 ton truck carries 8. One 7 thousand ton Navy Type 31 ship carries 12.
I am curious about the MANN 4X4 trucks that had just a 12 CAMM (2×6) on their back, might of been an 8, arrangement and If these are part of a CAMM battery arrangement as they’d be great multipliers.
12 CAMM is a pretty decent for for a second tier frigate like T31.
Not even close to fine. We have seen drone and missile waves in the hundreds against shipping. The world has changed and 12 missiles isnt even close to being able to defend a ship. Even against a single typhoon can in theory carry 12 missiles.
I think they do swarm game simulations. I have a vague memory that’s why T23 has 32. The T31 has the Bofors 57mm and 2x40mm guns. These are much more effective than the 2x 30mm on the T23 so I’m guessing T31 only needs 12 CAMM for equivalent protection.
I think it’s just down to cost, I don’t buy it’s purely a educated decision based on sims. The challange Ukraine has suffered with and so has Russia and the various middle eastern counties including the US, is it’s almost impossible to know if it’s a drone or a missile and so you can’t take a gamble with gun based short ranged defences and end up depleting missiles on low value targets.
They did very specific simulations based on RN requirements across a number of different weapons configurations.. the present set up was the most effective within the cost envelope at managing the target set the RN had given industry. I read a very interesting piece on it, it was the first time they had done it that way, normally the RN gives a list of weapons they want shoved on the ship.. this time they just gave permission to fit that best at doing x within cost y.
Good that they tried to optimise but within cost y doesn’t mean it’s good enough for the threat, just it’s as good as it could be.
Could be the RN provided a target set corresponding to the original T31 singleton patrol frigate role i.e. self defence but not local area defence, which arguably you would get from the larger the number of CAMM on a T23.
I’m not even sure the number of silos has been officially confirmed yet.
The new Mogami’s for the RAN will have the 11 shot RAM as well as the 4x mk41s. Bit same same then if T31s will have both mk41s and the 12 CAMM?
Second tier or not, twelve CAMMs to protect a £350+ million ship (costs have increased due to inflation, design changes, etc. plus GFE (missiles, etc.)), does not leave one with a stronge sense of security. Besides, it’s not uncommon to fire two missiles at a single target to ensure a kill.
One Army Sky Sabre 32 ton truck carries 8. One 7 thousand ton Navy Type 31 ship carries 12.
Once no statements were given at all. A competent observer could work out the numbers. But the point is, they could not be confirmed. I assume by the time the Minister answers his own question put to him in the Chamber by arrangement, the numbers of already available missiles are significant.
To be fair I think “security grounds” should become the norm. It’s not like they are withholding all information.
Do you know of any countries that *do* publish exact updates inventories of their air-to-air missile stocks?
This is one of the most common things nations are coy about, because it complicates adversary planning assumptions. It is often good to be sceptical of information being held back of grounds of national security, but this particular case is not one of them. It is entirely normal international practice, frustrating as that is.
In this case I’m totally with them, knowing exactly how many of these missiles the RN had would allow an enemy a significant advantage.
The existing stock being upgraded to Aster 30 block 1s includes the Aster 15s. Surely, they can’t all be converted until all the T45s have been given Sea Ceptor to cover close in engagements?
It doesn’t include the A15s.
The contracts make no mention of the A15s being updated and converted.
Additionally, the A15s never had the MLU that the A30s did.
As a result, they’ll be retired (or sent to Ukraine) once Sea Ceptor enters service on the T45s.
A15s and A30s are EXACTLY THE SAME, it is merely which booster they are attached to, small or large. Come on; this is Wikipedia stuff. Any A15 could be upgraded and attached too a large booster.
Indeed they are and the A15 -> A30 upgrade path was previously announced.
May have been announced (I can’t find anything governmental about it, and those ‘in-the-know’ indicate opposite), but it has not been contracted.
I also distinctly remember reading that the Aster 15’s would be converted to Aster 30’s by switching boosters, and then upgraded to the new standard.
Weird that all mention of that seemed to have disappeared.
A stealth cut maybe.
Maybe a stealth cut, or maybe a result of the slow CAMM integration with the T45s.
If we still need A15 in the early 2030s, it doesn’t make much sense to re-life them all right now.
They were never mid-life upgraded, either.
Did I claim they were not ‘EXACTLY THE SAME’? That they are is broadly irrelevant for the British situation.
Have we simply disregarded our ability to read?
Go look at the OCCAR documents, and then get back to me.
The demands on my time are formidable :/
If you don’t have time to do the research, don’t go around making readily disprovable statements, then.
Does anyone know if there is a difference between the Naval and land versions of Aster?
No, the missiles themselves are identical.
Also I believe that the SAAB Giraffe radar has been used to cue Aster 30 missiles (Singapore?). All that is needed is a suitable C2 network. If correct then it shouldn’t be hugely difficult to integrate Aster 30 Block 1 into the Army’s Land Ceptor system which would give the UK homeland a limited ABM and counter cruise missile capability as well asa very capable medium to long range anti aircraft capability, something that we badly need to defend High Value Assets such as bases, munition stores and key factories and shipyards.
Cheers CR
The thing is that Giraffe has an open API.
As I’ve said, more times than I can count, there isn’t any need for more radar just a way to get the data and controllers to control the launchers remotely. That goes for the UK’s Iron Umbrella – Geddit?
Agreed mate,
That was basically what I was suggesting i.e. integrate Aster into the existing batteries.
Cheers CR
And if they’re also currently manufacturing more Sky Sabre fire control units that would make good utilisation sense for a CAMM-Aster battery and a shared inventories pool.
Wonder now if the NS110 can also guide Aster on the T31s or if that’s asking too much? CAMM-MR would be a good in-between capability to have if its happening too.
I think the US has selected SAAB Giraffe for their FFX. No doubt they will be fitting it to T31 with CAMM and Aster 😂.
Be good if the UK sells the T31 to go with the radar. Lol
I just can’t wait to see what we strap these to in the 2030’s.
Aster is a French and Italian programme. There is no UK content. Citing the radar is as valid as citing the ships propulsion system……
The article is incorrect, but so are you.
You have to distinguish between design and production. The Aster is an entirely French-Italian design, but sub-components are manufactured in the UK (I think parts of the booster casing, for example, are made abroad).
“The Aster is an entirely French-Italian design” actually it isn’t totally true.
UK were part of the consortium for a while, in the Horizon era, and then left but we did make quite a few tech contributions.
Did we make contributions to the missile side of the design? We definitely contributed to horizon as a whole, but my understanding was Aster was an already mature programme we subsequently brought into.
Were our contributions not more related to the CMS portion of PAAMS, not the missiles?
Without reiterating my previous post I will say again that the Aster programme is French Italian. This being the case, they own the industrial methods of manufacturing on a 50 / 50 basis as per the programme agreement. Some minor components will likely come from elsewhere but this is different to citing a third country involvement in the background. The UK’s MBDA facility may get some industrial participation notw that it has been selected by the UK but this likely to be minor assembly and integration.
‘Advanced’.?
Sea Viper isn’t ’advanced’ – it’s now a fairly pedestrian missile who’s performance is way off the pace required of any primary air defence missile.
It’s too slow, it’s warhead is far too small, it’s legs are too short.
Just making shit up now, are we?
Yeah he is,
Aster 30 block 1 is still very competitive and Aster 30 block 1 NT is the next level up.
Aster was far ahead of SM 2 but now SM6 is the benchmark but it doesn’t mean Aster 30 is any form of slouch.
aster is tres merde – it’s tiny seeker severely limits its ability to take fast crossing targets – there’s a reason MDBA want a full bore terminal effector for Block 2 – big seeker, big warhead
As for Aster as currently exists?
It’s tiny 11Kg warhead give it near zero effect against stressing targets. It is what it is, a faster Sea Wolf class missile. It can’t even be fired at surface targets –
A ‘faster Sea Wolf class missile’ with 15 times the horizontal range and five times the maximum altitude?
They replaced the seeker to combat the issue you mention; that’s a major part of the B1NT programme.
Block 2 was shelved years ago and was never funded; I have little clue as to why people keep bringing it up.
It’s a HTK missile. The warhead is there as a lethality enhancer; PAC-3MSE has a similar mechanism. Something about slamming into your target with a closing velocity many times the speed of sound tends to do some damage.
And, beyond all of this, nothing you’ve mentioned here would suggest that the Aster is ‘way off the pace’ for a primary air defence interceptor. You’re comparing it at best in a negative light to SM-2IIIC, which is already a debateable conclusion. Globally, it’s on-par with, or ahead of the competition.
And SM-2? Now acquiring the SM-6 seeker so leaping with both feet into the active missile arena
From open sources (such as MBDA press releases), we have a rough idea of UK stocks. The original UK/France/Italy order was for 1400 Aster 15 and 30’s (c. 400 for RN?). France and Italy. but not not the UK, subsequently ordered another 700. Another joint order for 218 Aster 30 B1’s (c. 70 for RN?) was placed in 2025, with deliveries presumably starting next year. Allowing for two decades of test firings, plus a few operational firings, its reasonable to assume that the UK currently has enough Asters to give each of the six T45’s a full loadout with a mix of Aster 15s and 30’s, when the extra missiles arrive and Sea Ceptor is fitted, an Aster 30 only loadout will become the norm.
Going by my calculator 6 ships x 48 = 288. Nice for firing everything off the once but hopefully they have double this for backup and then some for land. Could they then add a quad,tri or dual plug insert for the T45 Sylver A50s to carry CAMM/ER/MR to add even more mass? Might as well utilise these ships while the RN still has them.
I remember the days of the Libyan intervention, op ellamy (I wasn’t at sea lol) when it was said, with some certainty (and confirmed by some sources) that one of the (type 23s?) had just 4 Sea Wolf missiles in its magazine? That was the time the Tories were ripping the RN to shreds if my memory is correct.
Ah I’ve made the effort to check, 2019, HMS Westminster, by that time the Tories had successfully destroyed the RN!
That was in the years the conservatives had managed to drag defence spending down to 1.8% of GDP.. least we forget when they get all holier than thou… as it had done for three years.. even with their 2015 fucking with the figures to include a far wider definition of defence spend.. adding in pensions, UN missions etc.. even if they had decency to keep it at above 2% it would have made a difference now.
Bugger…I never noticed the legs on an Aster…they are obviously too small!
Perhaps that’s why they can only get to mach 4.5 which is obviously WAY too slow to be of any use WHATSOEVER.
AA
Really AA? Do you know of any aircraft that do M4.5? Ballistic missiles only require interception, not usually chasing down, so M4.5 gives plenty of legs to cover a lot of ground before intercepting practically head on. Otherwise M4.5 will chase down most, if not any, aircraft easily & most cruise & supersonic missiles.
He’s being sarcastic.
The comment you should be directing your very correct statement at is a bit further above.
Oh, I see, thanks, “Just Me October 31, 2026 At 17:00” I presume. Didn’t seem like AA. It wasn’t posted as a reply but as a stand alone comment & I’m not as sharp as I once was.
No probs. Sarcasm isn’t usually the best reply…but I couldn’t help it.
AA
If only the naughty people weren’t deploying M8+ AShBMs at scale 🤔
Good news, no need to give out numbers I agree, but HMG love the fact they can say that same statement for any bit of hardware, upgrades, purchase plans etc! It’s an easy get out to hide the cans being kicked down the road, incompetence, fudging the facts or just plain politicking! Experience shows when this lot talk, you cannot take it on face value! To be fair it’s if any politician talks!!!!!
Indeed they love the banner headline/sound bite, but people think you’re talking the country down when you dig into the facts. Glad we’re making some progress. Will we have enough & in the right places when we need them though?All the Ruskies need to do is launch a load of decoy/dummy missiles at us to exhaust our missiles before making the actual strikes.
Agreed mate but does any military have enough air defence missiles? Ukraine and certainly Iran has shown how quickly you can eat through all your stores and munitions. But I have to say, grudgingly, that there is a bit of movement from HMG regarding both our infrastructure/resilience for defence and stocks. Not enough, not quick enough but its going in the (slowly) right direction.
It’s interesting really, Ukraine are using loads of reactivated or just plain old AAW missiles to good effect.. infact there are cases of 19080s air defence missiles knocking down modern cruise missiles. So it seems Ukraine has to an extent managed to keep fighting due to that old soviet idea of stash everything in a warehouse just incase..
When you think sea dart after it was linked with a radar that was not utter dog was infact a very competent missile ( a ramjet with powered manoeuvring up to its maximum range is useful ) and the mod 3s were manufactured in 2002 meaning they would only be 24 years old. Same with sea Wolf last manufactured and upgraded in 2005.
I know people will go.. but Obsolescence… well if ukriane can manage to bring down a modern cruise missile with a 40 year old missile.. maybe we could have managed the Obsolescence..
It’s why if they are determined to bin warrior they should shove them in a warehouse.. along with every CR, 105mm gun system ect.. because having something to reactive is better than just the trickle of newly manufactured systems.
Sadly the British way is to dispose of it..
One of the programs looking at a more advanced Sea Dart was very interesting. Which included a vertical launch capability, along with exhaust vanes for improved steering. But also replacing a lot of the early transistor based electronics with processor based electronics, which allowed for more space for fuel. Along with a better cruising quasi-ballistic flight profile, range would have matched the current Aster 30 Block 0. However, as it used semi-active radar homing (SARH) for target guidance, it would have been a lot cheaper to manufacture, than a missile that uses an active radar seeker. The exhaust steering would have been useful, especially as Sea Dart was ramjet powered. So although it wouldn’t match the 60g+ manoeuvrability or overall speed of Aster 30, it would have been good enough to intercept cruise missiles that use a form of terminal manoeuvring, as well as short range ballistic missiles such as Scud and their variants.
The fact that UK is not buying Aster B1NT which is much more advanced makes me think if this is the end of the line for Aster,
and next SAM will be American – the only other viable alternative – and MK41 choice for other reasons may in the end influence it.
ASTER is a dead end since Block 2 was quietly dropped.
B1NT is the next part of the SVE programme.
I have had quite a few posts questioning my commwent about the government using “national security” as an excuse. Forgive me if I answer all together. Over the last thirty months we ahve had Ther Strategic Defence Review, which was delayed. Defence Investment Programme, delayed, Cadet Force investment, delayed, Resilience paper, delayed. Defence procurement, delayed, Defence spending review, delayed. Over the same time period we have had cancellations, disposals, postponments and now an increasing number of questions not answered on so called security issues. Well, forgive my cynicsism but I have seen nothing from this government in thirty months that gives me any cause for optimism.
Follwing on from my post above the chancellor has said that three per cent by 2030 is a target, not a commitment. Good job he resigned on “principle” to get his promotion really.
The security argument for not revealing numbers is incredibly weak. Numbers of all kinds of UK military assets are published on a routine basis.
And why not? Does anyone seriously think Putin’s actions would be in the slightest bit changed by knowing the UK has a 100 Asters or 200 or 300???
It’s a bullshit excuse to spare government blushes.
Actually yes, because if we got into a shooting war, Russia could estimate usage of the missile and then attack with its most expensive and precious capabilities at a point our air defence is at its weakest.