A Royal Navy ship has delivered critical water and medical supplies to Tonga in the wake of a catastrophic tsunami.
The Royal Navy say here that as soon as HMS Spey arrived in the Tongan capital Nuku’alofa on the island of Tongatapu, her 50 crew began offloading 30,000 litres of bottled water, medical supplies and sanitation and baby care products.
“The islands’ capital is serving as the hub for an international aid effort supporting the stricken Commonwealth nation. The aid, which Spey collected from Tahiti last week, will be distributed around islands most severely affected by the tsunami, which was triggered by an extremely rare underwater volcanic eruption on January 15, destroying homes and covering the area in volcanic ash.”
Chief Petty Officer Ash Head said in a press release:
“It is hot out in the sun, so it is good to see the whole ship’s company working together, rotating positions where needed and keeping water bottles topped up. We are looking after each other and we are glad our work can support international aid efforts and help Tonga.”
One advantage having such a vessel forward deployed.
And an example of “Global Britain” which means the UK involved around the world, as it has been for hundreds of years. In trade, diplomacy, aid, soft power, Not just military reach and how many ships, planes or Tanks and “Empire”, as the lefty luvvies snear as their chip on their shoulder instantly catches fire!
Excellent comment. Perhaps the most significant part of what our armed forces do is not that visible but hugely important.
Absolutely! Very easy to talk about being more globally engaged but it’s things like vessels turning up and delivering soft power that shows it.
Good one Daniele. I was waiting to hear when the RN would arrive along with the Aussies and Kiwis. The Commonwealth is a force for good.
31 degrees in Durban today- Weather report says feels like 36 degrees coz of the humidity!
Cheers my friend(on the next RIB to Dover ) 😂
I read that post….wholeheartedly agree.
Superb! Absolutely we must do more of this to support the remote Pacific and Atlantic islands in our sphere of influence. I wish we could have done more to help places like Antigua a few years back when the big hurricane hit there.
I’ve always thought, in these humanitarian situations, you never see the Russians or Chinese delivering tons of aid. I can’t remember them ever doing so. Mind you – Tonga isn’t exactly a strategic country for either of them, so they wouldn’t get any return for their largesse.
However, if the Russians/Chinese did start sending in aid, we (the West) would start to get suspicious anyway – they can’t win!
Not one to offer support to China or Russia but do we only not see their aid as it is not shown on our news or do they genuinely not often send any?
Good question
After Typhoon Haiyan hit the Philippines in Nov 2013 killing 6300 people, Aid was sent from across the world the top 10 were:
Uk: $131 Million
US: $86 Million
Australia: $70 Million
Japan : $52 Million
Holland: $49 Million
Norway: $41.6 million
Canada: $40 Million
South Korea: $25 Million
Kuwait: $10 Million
Saudi Arabia: $10 Million
In addition The UK deployed HMS Daring and HMS Illustrious and Royal Air Force C-130J – stationed in Cebu delivering over 235,000 of aid – and Royal Air Force Boeing C-17 Globemaster III for Humanitarian Aid and Relief
The US Deployed the USS George Washington (CVN-73) and her embarked carrier strike group, along with the 31st Marine Expeditionary Unit, embarked aboard the USS Ashland and USS Germantown, of Amphibious Squadron 11. At its peak, the U.S. military efforts included more than 13,400 military personnel from the US Marine Corps, US Navy and US Air Force. 66 aircraft were involved in the mission including the fixed-wing C17 Globemaster, C-130 Hercules and MV-22 Osprey of the 3rd Marine Expeditionary Brigade, as well as MH-60 Seahawk helicopters. 12 U.S. Navy vessels responded in all.
China handed over $1.4 million and sent the 300 bed hospital ship Daishan Dao ,
Russia sent no money, just 200 helpers.
Also not mentioned by many but at the same time the Chinese sent the Chinese aircraft carrier Liaoning task force (four escort ships) to gallivant off the coast of the Philippines in a show of force. Yet it was never sent to offer the use of its Helichopters.
Oh just for the record France handed over $1.4 Million
Interesting. However what about in areas where Russia is traditionally allied to? They may well be pretty selfish with their money though, unless it involves sending troops to help quell civilian protests against dictators…
Lee,
Thank you for replying, I was kind of substantiating Daniele’s initial post where he pointed out that actually the Uk isn’t as intolerant, far right and bigoted as the wonk brigade make out and that when push comes to shove we do more than others in which to help our fellow man than those whom the left of the political centre demand we ape.
Using the term woke is not helpful in a meaningful discussion. It is derogatory and fails to recognise that the right have their fair share of people who get offended by stupid things.
But yes we as a people have always been giving and I am not sure that has ever been in question. That is not the same as the permanent foreign aid budget issue though. I think we were wrong to cut that just as China is using theirs to influence (and trap them) into moving under their influence. Foreign aid budgets have never really been about pure aid but about influence and by reducing ours we risk losing influence.
Emergency aid though is purely a good morally right thing to do and we are very good at that.
Woke is absolutely a perversion. It is hybrid warfare directed at creating anarchy. It is spread by social and other media to groom converts and is no less dangerous than the grooming of vulnerable young Islamic extremists. Remember the pen is mightier than the sword. The Graudian is wholesale intellectual mood killing.
I am not sure you even have an idea what it actually is. I mean my Dad has been called Woke for getting an Electric car despite him being firmly old school right wing! It is a term invented by the far right to excuse their behaviour and is intended as a divisive and destabilising term. There are plenty of people on both sides of the political spectrum who get easily offended and shout very loud about it while the rest of us just get on with being good human beings. Woke went from being a far right terminology to being used against anyone arguing against any injustice or even those making morally correct choices. It is worryingly now getting thrown at people simply accepting scientific fact!
Lets stop with the childish name calling and talk to each other like actual grown ups…
lee wrote:
Currently the BBC is pushing a story about how third world countries aren;t getting free hand outs of C19 vaccines via COVAX and that the Uk must hand over more instead of vacinating its own. But here is my gripe, at the start of 2020 and until the end of 2020 everybody in the world was in the same boat Some countires planned , some didn;t . So 3 third world countries:
Paksitan
Tunisia
iran
All 3 depend on COVAX for their vaccines, and yet all 3 have spent billions on their miltary for weapons they don’t need:
Only the other week Paksitan ordered 25 J10 aircraft from China, it has a bigger airforce, navy and army
Tunisia has purchased a load of kit it doesnt rerally need including the latest Turksish killer drones, Iran, is the worst of them all, in fact it goes out of its way to kill (thousands in 2020) people who protest about spending money at home.
yet the wonks want the UK which has not only handed over the biggest single payment to COVAX it (as of dec) had handed over 30 million vaccines to third world countries with an extra 70 million sheduled for this year. to send even more, But get this when the Uk started planning for the vaccine roll out, one of the things Van Tam did was ensure everywhere where vaccines would be rolled out would have the correct fridges which could store the vaccines. As i pointed out above we were all in the same boat in 2020, yet so many african countries had to ditch millions of doses of vaccines because they hadn’t bothered to plan for storage or distrubution, My point, why should the Uk be bereated for poor planning by others such as the woke generation who subscribe to this notion that the Uk is remiss in its aid program. As i pointed out in my orginal post the UK hands over more gelt than most other countries (such as more aid to Syria than the rest of the EU combined) and I for one I’am glad of that, but you know what, I am sick to my back teeth at how the woke crowd don’t see that and continue to disparge my country. Don’t even get me started on how the wokes rant on about slavery and about black lies matter and I’m the child of Islamic migrants to the Uk
What has that got to do with being Woke? That situation has been happening for the whole time civilisation has existed…
If we want to be free of covid then we need to make sure the majority of the world is vaccinated. Otherwise the chances of new vaccine escaping variants is high. We as a rich country should indeed help and we have. However we have given over £500million to the program but the cheaper and more effective way to do it would have been to simply release IP restrictions on the vaccine but we refuse to do that.
The idea that Pakistan, Iran and Tunisia etc getting free vaccines while they spend on military equipment is obviously wrong but it is important to support the people of those countries who do not necessarily have a say in what their Governments decide to do.
And yet closer to home we have record use of food banks and homelessness is still to common yet we are one of the riches countries in the world. You could also argue perhaps we should solve our own internal problems rather than taking very expensive private aircraft trips to Australia and making sure friends of ministers get paid large amounts for PPE Contracts. Should we as the fifth richest country in the world rely on charities to feed our poor? I would say no we shouldn’t.
Lee wrote:
“”What has that got to do with being Woke? “”
You tell me, I wrote ‘wonk’ and you read it as woke. You started the ball rolling.
Lee wrote:
“However we have given over £500million to the program”
A quick butchers at the covax website shows the Uk has handed over $3 billion, which is more than anybody else, the next is the US at $2.7 billion.
Lee wrote:
“” but the cheaper and more effective way to do it would have been to simply release IP restrictions on the vaccine but we refuse to do that.””
There is some merit in what you say, but as today not one country has done that, saying that any country can apply to produce the AZ vaccine Only india has done so.
Lee wrote:
“”The idea that Pakistan, Iran and Tunisia etc getting free vaccines while they spend on military equipment is obviously wrong but it is important to support the people of those countries who do not necessarily have a say in what their Governments decide to do.””
So you subscribe to the notion that Pakistan (the biggest recipient of British aid can continue to fund its much larger miltary
Tanks:
Uk 227
Pakistan: 2906
Fighter jets:
Uk 158 (of which the 21 F35s are not really a fighter aircraft
Pakistan:582
Nukes:
Uk: 120
Pakistan: 165
Space program:
Uk: nil
Pakistan: yes
whislt the Uk funds its social security program
Lee wrote:
And yet closer to home we have record use of food banks and homelessness is still to common yet we are one of the riches countries in the world
2000 food banks across the Uk, the same number as in Germany, they can also be found across Europe including Sweden,Denmark and Norway, but heres an interesting snippet the rise in the use of food banks across the Uk began when the Uk changed from handing money to people who rent and such direct to the person in need. Then lets not forget family credit, child benefit, and such. For example the parents of the manchester bomber were pulling in £2000 a month in benefits , and they were still getting paid that despite moviing to Libya..
Lee wrote:
“”rather than taking very expensive private aircraft trips to Australia “”
Do you think Truss, flew just by herself to Australia , or did she have her’s (and the defences se) entourage in tow then theres their security detachment so you are looking at an additional; 40 people at least, as I have partaken in such, I can tell you the media have been a little remiss in not mentioning such.
Lee wrote:
“”Should we as the fifth richest country in the world rely on charities to feed our poor? “”
Nobody should go hungry in the UK, we have a support sysytem which tends to people which includes free medical care, yes some people will fall through the cracks, but the vast majority are catered for, if they would rather spend their benefits on other things rather than on their chidren, they are too blame. Now if I could feed my sisiter and I whilst living in the cellar on the money I made from a paper round,as a child, I’m pretty sure than others can feed their own from the money the state gives them. Have you been to the supermarket and watched what people buy, processed meals, expensive, fat,salt and sugar laden, if they can’t be bothered to shop around, and instead play the victim card in which to excuse themselves, why is it the governments fault. and why do people like you use emotive language instead of facts to state your case.
Come back to the board with actual facts rather than using emotion in which to try and claim the moral highground.
So firstly, what the hell is “Wonk”
Actually the covax website along with other sources put the UKs contribution at $735 million which equates to £548 million https://www.gavi.org/sites/default/files/covid/covax/COVAX-AMC-Donors-Table.pdf
Why should we do the same as other countries with regard to IP? It would have been the cheapest option so would benefit both the UK and the rest of the world… I am not sure India applied. AZ contracted them to produce vaccines as it already had partners in India.
Not sure what you are trying to say with regards to my comment about Pakistan etc. I clearly said it was wrong that they spend on military while claiming aid… However the people do not make those decisions. You are saying I support Pakistan’s spending, I clearly do not.
Cleary there are ways of manipulating the Benefits system, However the majority do not do so and are therefore not pulling in £2000 per month. My wife is a teacher and is currently dealing with a number of students whose families can no longer afford food and are having to go to food banks. They are not getting anywhere near that much in the slightest. Highlighting a single case of injustice is not a good way to work out if the system is correct or not… Some of the children my wife deals with are getting their only proper meal each day from school… They regularly break down in tears and the school regularly brings in the parents to discuss the situations. I can tell you that the parents she deals with are not spending money where it is not needed.
Having a free at point of source medical system is fantastic but it is not the NHS that pays for food or for energy bills, transport, rent etc. Not sure what the NHS has to do with my comment.
Lee wrote:
Actually the covax website along with other sources put the UKs contribution at $735 million which equates to £548 million
Really as here is a screen dump from the excel sheet found on their funders link:
That is not Covax… that is GAVI.
Lee wrote:
Please, I’m a child who had to find clothes to wear from the local tip, I worked 2 paperrounds to put food on the table for my sisiter and I, kind of explains why we were taken into care. I came from nothing and I have made something of my life and I grew up in a childrens home. If children are going hungry, what are their parents doing with their child benefit?
I stated that you resort to using emotion in which to try and claim the moral highground, and guess what, you did it again. Problem is, I’m the wrong bloke for you to try that card on.
I am not using emotion to gain the moral high ground. If you feel that way then that is on you not me.
I congratulate you on making something of yourself despite your background. However I too had a similar experience growing up and I too now have made a very good living. That does not mean that I think I should have grown up like that… I do not wish it on others and do not subscribe to the old fashioned view of other having to go through what I went through. Child hunger has significant effects on educational outcomes which in turn makes it much harder for those children to secure good jobs.
What are the parents spending their benefits on? Well Rent is a major one and that has been going up, food prices have increased dramatically especially for essential foods. Inflation overall is something like 5% at the moment, the inflation on essential items is actually more like 10%. Then there are the costs of keeping a car on the road and filling it with petrol. I know one person who is having to pay out for cladding issues on their flat! It is easy to pick out a handful of cases where people are misusing their benefits and that does happen. However the vast majority of people at food banks do not wish to be there and are not misusing their benefits at all.
Sorry Lee1, but their debt was wiped in 2008, they then went out and borrowed from China. Those countries are back in the same boat they were in 2006, debt to their eye balls and spending stupid amounts on Arms.
I agree that the current imperative is to scale existing vaccines as quickly as possible while maintaining strict safety and quality standards. But for the premise of this debate to be true, there would need to be additional manufacturers who could and would stand ready to manufacture additional vaccines if not thwarted by IP restrictions. I see no evidence that is currently the case—and, to the contrary, believe taking an antagonistic posture toward IP may actually slow or compromise production.
Innovator companies are under enormous commercial and geopolitical pressure to scale as quickly as possible to meet enormous, immediate demand. Their profit-driven interest, in this case, is aligned with the global imperative to increase production. To do so, they are already cooperating widely with competitors and generic manufacturers, including via voluntary licenses, contracted production, and proactive technology transfer. Diluting that commercial incentive may reduce their interest in pursuing the voluntary horizontal collaborations that are already driving scale.
It is also not clear that any additional generic manufacturers are “standing by” ready to produce. Under existing TRIPS flexibilities, countries can already issue compulsory licenses to produce vaccines without permission from the patent-holder. None have done so. Voluntary licensing and technology transfer from originator companies can help increase long-term manufacturing capacity, especially if paired with public investment; originators also have an interest in enforcing safety and quality control standards while doing so, which is especially important in the context of widespread vaccine hesitancy. Their cooperation is important for both speed and quality, and so far they seem willing to play ball.
To be clear, I am not arguing that IP protections always serve the public good; nor am I necessarily ruling out a future scenario in which IP becomes a major challenge for global access. But all evidence suggests the current constraint to global access is capacity, not legal strictures.
👍
Farouk, I agree with you 110%
I remember when some people on this website did not like the idea of five new River class patrol ships being built. I always believed they would be very useful.. Taking pressure off the larger ship’s. “Well done to all involved”
Agree, always liked the B2s. I’d like 5 more!
Too many only see “defence” as how big a bang it makes and not the myriad capabilities and non wary roles that defence offers.
I would like to see them a little up-armed is all. Not to spend too much but some more.
Aid delivery is now a right-wing talking point Daniele? Black is white and up is down too? I’m no defender of Labor in the UK, but this is gaslighting plain and simple. All Britons should be able to take pride in what HMS Spey is doing without being subjected to an unwarranted political attack. This is the Farage type sentiment that makes Britain seem old and inward-looking, not the Global Britain you think you represent.
Well said. Daniele’s otherwise excellent contributions to this site are undermined by such foolish comments.
I refer you to the Guardian’s opinions on the UK getting involved in the far East “post imperial nostalgia ” I believe they called it??
Glad you like my other comments though Matt, but to me there is nothing foolish for calling out that sort. I’ve been called a fascist to my face before. It works both ways.
Daniele wrote wrote:
”I’ve been called a fascist to my face before “
A few years back whilst on leave , my best mate and I came across this anti US stand , anyway , the geezer must have presumed by the colour of my skin , I would support his cause and sign his petition, I refused, he went from peace protester to foaming at the mouth idiot in seconds and called me a fascist. I simply replied “ Err according to your rule book, I’m the wrong colour to be a fascist “ talk about stumped. You could actually see how his train of thought was boarding at the station at that, he then , I kid you not, threatened to beat me up, I laughed, he became more aggressive and as I moved towards him, he started backing off screaming he could have me, by the time he got about 50 feet away, I stopped and walked away. What a plank.
Morning farouk.
Wonderful story. They cannot cope with reality checks that their ideological world is not always like they want it to be.
Mine was out on campaign for Farage in Thanet in 2015. We knocked on a door, introduced ourselves, and the lad said “Sorry, I don’t talk with fascists” and closed the door before we could say a word.
Clearly another brainwashed by the anti UKIP campaign.
Cameron called us all “closet racists and loons” That went down well didn’t it?
So, that is 4 million plus who all voted for UKIP in the 2015 GE, and the 52% who are fascists.
I suppose every other person in all independent nations on earth who wish to remain so are all fascists too!
Colour? Yes, I was surprised at how many coloured people were at the pre campaign get together, which was some thousands not the few hundred the BBC ( as usual ) described it as. They were mostly black guys ( am I even allowed to say that now I lose track ) and one Muslim lad straight out of the Taliban dress catalogue. There’s a picture of me posing with him out on the net somewhere.
Boring old chestnuts farouk! They know not what they speak.
I wouldn’t say undermined but i do roll my eyes at times. That said, he’s a poster on a forum. All non prejudicial posts welcome. Always good to read thoughts contrary to our own. Not as if we’re looking for marriage prospects
Agreed Damo. One reason I keep coming back to this site is not only the excellence of reporting by George, but also the invaluable opinions of the commentators who have immensely more knowledge and experience than I. I read the Gaurdian and the Telegraph each day, and am always depressed by some of the ignorant or ridiculous opinions that apparently deserve printing in both.
No, aid delivery isn’t. But having ships deployed in the far east to enable that delivery quickly is, which is what the Guardian was complaining about, likening to empire, and which I was referencing.
And considering in a previous thread you told one commentator that I was “not worth replying to” when giving a different viewpoint to yours and his, I’m now going against my better judgement even bothering to reply to you.
Best leave it there.
Mate you are pretty much spot on and consistent with your view point! Never an issue with me, keep it up.
Mate, respect.
Differences of opinion are fine.
Being treated like shit is not, and I will respond accordingly.
Your point is non-existent Daniele. You didn’t even reference a source for your, “The Guardian made me do it!”, excuse. Trashing liberal democracy as we raise the sails isn’t the way to represent Global Britain. It’s human nature for youth to be more progressive than their parents. There’s plenty of left-leaning youth to be inspired by the good work HMS Spey is doing, perhaps even some on board. It’s an excellent opportunity for the RN to showcase some of the good work it does and engage idealistic youth. You did your level best to sabotage that in the name of some right wing political agenda. If defense recruitment is the exclusive domain of right wingers we are headed for a dangerous place occupied by autocrats. Our enemies are not left wing communists, they are right wing dictators with little in common with their communist, ideologue predecessors. Regardless of intentions, your actions sabotage recruitment efforts of the RN which needs a larger recruiting base to grow. Perhaps you are aware of this fact. Perhaps that’s why I, for the most part, choose not to engage you.
All Britons should, but the sad fact is many on the left don’t/can’t/refuse to see the bigger picture in regard to forward deployed assets, as their political viewpoint clashes with the concept! Small minds are seen on both left and right of the political spectrum but the difference is that the left always like to think they have the moral high ground and like to cause more noise, to shout other opinions down!
I refer you to my reply to Daniele, I’m a centrist.
So am I! But Ron Stateside knows differently.
I have read some tosh in my time on this site but that takes the biscuit.
““The Guardian made me do it!”
No, I choose to comment as I see fit. I do not need to provide a reference for anything. If you don’t know the Guardians reputation by now with some of the tosh in it and equally some of the same beliefs that appear here and in wider society which I am equally opposed to then…
“Trashing liberal democracy as we raise the sails isn’t the way to represent Global Britain.”
Amazing, you really think I’m doing that while I’m actually praising it!
“It’s human nature for youth to be more progressive than their parents. There’s plenty of left-leaning youth to be inspired by the good work HMS Spey is doing, perhaps even some on board. It’s an excellent opportunity for the RN to showcase some of the good work it does and engage idealistic youth.”
I agree! But I don’t recall the Guardian writers who wrote any of the pieces I’m thinking of being youths so what has that got do do with anything I wrote? And if other youngsters are “more progressive” ( nice wording ) then I equally might have an opinion on that.
“You did your level best to sabotage that in the name of some right wing political agenda.”
Wow, you really believe that don’t you? And what agenda are the “progressive” Guardian editors pushing that so many, including me, disagree with.
“If defense recruitment is the exclusive domain of right wingers we are headed for a dangerous place occupied by autocrats.”
Which I assume it isn’t, as I’m not in the RN.
“Regardless of intentions, your actions sabotage recruitment efforts of the RN which needs a larger recruiting base to grow.”
I will laugh at that comment to my dying day, Ron Stateside.
Sound just like what Airborne mentions below, the left shouting down other opinions they cannot deal with. In fact this whole episode is typical.
“Perhaps you are aware of this fact. Perhaps that’s why I, for the most part, choose not to engage you.”
No, total cop out. You make references to me in the 3rd person, extremely rude, as if I am some freak simply because I had a differing opinion to MX who wants 1st strikes on Putin, says I am a traitor, and cannot accept differing views on this site. That view in question being no, I do not want war with Russia over a non NATO nation, Ukraine.
Happy to provide a link to said article for all readers!!
You will never win. I will voice my opinions if they are within the rules of this site, with respect, and good manners.
I LOVE the irony how there are so many other right wing views on this site, including ones which suggest migrants are drowned, shot in the waters after their boats are destroyed, and even a suggestion that the channel be set alight….all that actually on Holocaust remembrance day, yet there is barely a peep of outrage.
You and others clearly are more irked by me than those horrors.
Good. That means you see me as a threat that needs shouting down ( see Airborne’s comments )
I will continue. If you don’t like me throwing the occasional snipe ( as many do here, the others you ignore ) and voicing my opinions then, tough.
Sorry to continue, but just had a “lightbulb moment” while doing the gardening! And cannot let the sheer hypocricy pass.
Regards my comment in post above regards earlier exchanges re Russia –
“No, total cop out. You make references to me in the 3rd person, extremely rude, as if I am some freak simply because I had a differing opinion to MX who wants 1st strikes on Putin, says I am a traitor, and cannot accept differing views on this site. That view in question being no, I do not want war with Russia over a non NATO nation, Ukraine.”
Who’s the right winger now? Regards Russia / Ukraine, over many articles over many months, I try to talk peace, try to see the enemy viewpoint, try to be civil to Ulya, our Russian resident commentator, suggest minimal reactions to Russia’s provocations without escalating, and so on and so on. And you defend MX who I am debating with, who in one comment recently actually said ( another snipe, but against me its obviously OK… ) that a am becoming “More of a pacifist lately”
Pacifist? And I’M the raging right winger???
My positions on that subject are clearly more left leaning than right. You know? Peace, and all that? Speak softly and carry a big stick? And you told the obvious hawk, right wing poster in MX who wants to conduct 1st strikes on Russia’s nuclear stockpile to ignore me as “anyone who supports a mafia state is not worth a reply from you”
And you’re a “centrist” ? Applauding comments like that yet taking issue with my original snipe at the left that started this exchange?
😂I simply cannot take you seriously any longer with the sheer irony.
Boom! Daniele shoots, two rounds to the centre of the body mass, man down……👍
Lol he got his knickers in a tight bunch and couldn’t address a single point of mine, all gaslighting and whatabout this, what about that. Great critical thinking skills there mate and no, I’m still standing.
Fact is not gaslighting, whataboutism, and heresy. I’ll let you look up what critical thinking skills are. As to your threats I’ll leave it up to the site owner or GCHQ I thought it was a non-political site.
Lol sounds like you got your knickers in a real bunch! You again can’t address a single point of mine; all gaslighting and whataboutism. You spend all day on this site every day Daniele and can’t stand it if you don’t go home with the most lego blocks. Sad.
You couldn’t resist the lefty snipe could you lol 😆
Hi Damo. It’s true. Guilty as charged.
At least you can laugh and I will reply in kind.
I myself actually have both left and right wing views.
Whatever. Having been called a fascist for merely wanting the UK to leave the EU, a great exaggeration I think, I will speak my mind.
Clearly, there are some very sensitive folk out there.
Definitely. I too flit between the 2. Everyday is a learning day. No one needs echo chambers
The sad thing is that there are a large amount of people aka sheep who will blindly follow the party lead no matter where it takes them! Sensible politics is about supporting those ideas and innovations which are for the good and benefit of the country and it’s people, regardless which party came up with it! I’m bored off my tits with the continued sad, pathetic, political arguing and competition, supported by useful idiots who continue to vote for party colour not policies! Cheers mate
My thinking exactly. It’s the blind following and backing someone no matter how crazy they are acting. Everyone has made bad decisions as some times the most important thing is being able to say I f***ed up, sorry it was a mistake I should of done this instead and will learn from this
Absolutely! Also shows what a capable vessel the batch 2 river class are, and what an advantage it is for them to be forward based…
The Senior Service has been doing this type of operation for years and the ships deployed can provide a lot more to the locals, power and such too have in the past been directly provided from the ships. BZ the crew
There you go….now we see why they have a crane and a large deck for containers rather than a helo and hangar. Good work 👍
If you could have a telescopic hangar at least that would help as per navy lookout options. Could you ever also push the crane back a bit and leave a spot for a phalanx CIWS? Enhancing the Royal Navy’s batch II OPVs | Navy Lookout
Tempting…I think there is a valid global role for these batch 2 OPVs. But I don’t see them operating as singleton patrol frigates. We will have forward based T31 for that, and supposedly we can expect 5 x T32.
I do see the value of being able to lily pad a medium helo for refuelling, re-arming or extending the reach of ASW and AEW Merlins say; but I see the maintenance crews and hangars staying on the task force ships and/or RFA’s for humanitarian work etc.
For constabulary work a containerised UAV for surveillance would be valuable and probably all you need.
Agree where you are going with Phalanx; anti air is a weakness for the R2s. A 40mm would be good. I think the RN has evaluated the 30mm Martlet combo and decided against it. Not sure it offers anything over the Bofors. So overall I would do the Navy Lookout OPV Plus option. Cheers.
Whilst your point about UAV’s is valid, I personally still think that the utility, and more importantly the ability of a helo deliver a boarding party far quicker than an RHIB, over a longer range would be extremely useful even if these vessels are only the equivalent of the old bills panda car.
The old Sea Lynx with a GPMG would have been perfect.
If you are doing a boarding go by boat.
If you are doing an opposed boarding…go by boat.
From experience packing everyone into the back of a Lynx , sat on the floor with 120ft of rope on your lap is not great.
Neither is roping onto a deck with a shed load of boarding kit on.
Its good for getting their quickly as a back up to a sea boat or for providing top cover with a sniper.
That said it was bloody good fun roping out when we did need to do it.
Well I bow to your superior knowledge and experience.
I was just thinking that a relatively simple helo could provide a more versatile and flexible capability when running down drug runners and pirates.
I suppose that the next gen OPV’s might benefit from a small UAV and perhaps an extendable hangar to accommodate a land based hello nearby.
Tend to agree. Sadly in the end it comes down to cost: +5 helos and 5 flight crews and 5 maintenance crews.
Here’s some video of the Australian and New Zealand aid effort to Tonga.
Australia:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=p1cQRzKuaxc
New Zealand:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0nUe8Aggc-Y
Cheers,
Great work HMS Spey. Well done.
Good work, our presence in this area has proven to be crucial.
Answer me a riddle, _what’s grey, flies a white Ensign, is manned by Officers, mateloes and Marines, and has bang sticks fitted. Discuss.
Sorry M Franks, this was for Andy Reeves. My bad.
No problem mate.
painting a patrol boat grey doesn’t make it a warship
DH 🙂 Hmmm, RFAs?? 😉
Well it has a gun. And warship standard features.
The Archers are not warships either, but they are still grey, and still have a role.
But being built to warship standards with the correct systems, support, comms etc does. Research these platforms and it’s quite amazing what has gone into them, which not many without subject matter knowledge realises.
Absolutely, and a good demonstration of why they are the size they are and not very much smaller.
For my two penn’orth, I would like a 40mm Bofors and a Malloy type heavy lift drone on board. The drone can lift aid supplies and be used to take aloft some sort of reconnaissance package, whilst the gun is capable, and I am thinking of engaging ever more plentiful uav’s, but not so big to turn it into a frigate in the eyes of a politician.
Hopefully of course the ships are likely to serve their turn without needing to fire the existing gun.
AA
Off topic does anyone know how many raf aircraft went to red flag. I’ve hunted loads of websites but no numbers and all I can find is pictures with 2 typhoons parked up and the tanker. The 1 tanker has crews from both squadrons there.
Would it just be 2? I would of thought 4 would be minimum just to get useful pilot hours etc
No idea either, but agree 2 would be far too few. I recall it is usually half a squadrons worth plus tanker, transport, and, at one time, ASCS support.
You would think they would want to boast about being able to deploy this many aircraft 5000 miles etc but I can still find nothing. 6 pictures of 2 typhoons and 1 voyager. For 2020 red flag the had to move 250 tons of equipment, some airlifted some by sea etc.
Hopefully more news to follow. Some videos of low level, escort big aircraft etc would be great PR. Send it to the main news outlets and hope for a slow news day
Look up “RAF News” on the MoD RAF site.
Headline – “RAF arrive in US in large scale exercise” has 2 photos. One with 5 Typhoon visible at bottom of page, the other with parts of at least 4 visible on flight line with cockpits open.
So my guess is still 6 ( or 5 ) Typhoon ( from 1 Sqn ) and as 41R are there maybe one or 2 more.
As a Brit living in NZ It’s nice to have the Royal Navy operating in the area again.
Hopefully some exercises or a port visit may happen sometime in the future. Must be due a Royal Navy circumnavigation of the world sometime soon. Maybe next carrier deployment.
Tad unfortunate name for the CPO in the Press Release, when you consider the event (I know, it’s trying to be light hearted).
In a few years time, it will be good to see one or two more RN ships posted in the region.